Which is better for a beginner?

The Pillow Talk quad. Four color-coded shades are harder to get wrong than twelve, and the formula is described as easy to blend.

Which has more matte shades?

Naked3. Its primary finishes are matte and satin, while Pillow Talk mixes satin-matte with metallic and shimmer.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

Naked3. It is listed as hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive skin; Pillow Talk is listed for normal skin.

Is Pillow Talk worth the extra?

It is not extra right now. At $35.00 on November 2 it is $5.00 cheaper than Naked3 at $40.00, though it was $56.99 on October 30.

Which lasts longer on the eyes?

Both are listed as waterproof pressed powders. Neither listing gives a wear time, so the difference is unproven.

Which is better for dark skin tones?

Naked3 is explicitly listed as suitable for dark skin tones. Pillow Talk's listing makes no such claim.

Urban Decay Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette vs Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette Pillow Talk

Buy the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk quad if you want a compact, easy-to-blend everyday set of four shades. Buy the Urban Decay Naked3 if you want a larger rose-neutral palette with more matte options and a lower ceiling on price. On the latest daily prices, Pillow Talk is cheaper at $35.00 versus $40.00 for Naked3, both as of November 2. Pillow Talk's price has swung from $56.99 on October 30, so the gap may not hold.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.