Vail Counter & Bar Stool vs Lumisource Cosmo Mid-Century Bar Stool

The Vail is the sturdier, more finished stool: a powder-coated steel frame, channel-tufted upholstery and leather strap detailing, backed by a very high owner rating. The Lumisource Cosmo is a lighter mid-century design with a padded seat and a taller 26-inch seat height, but its mixed leather, wood and bamboo build and California Proposition 65 warning make it the less durable, less reassuring pick. Buy the Vail for daily use at a counter or bar; pick the Cosmo only if you want its specific mid-century look and need the extra seat height.

• Choose the Vail if you want a solid, well-reviewed stool with a steel frame and upholstered comfort for everyday seating.
• Choose the Lumisource Cosmo if you want a lighter mid-century look and a taller seat for a higher counter.