Which is better for a family with pets?

The Valencia. Its leather is described as scratch-resistant and the cushion covers come off for cleaning. The Galligher's cushions are attached, so stains stay on the piece.

The Valencia, on paper. It uses top grain leather, a solid alder frame and high-resiliency foam. The Galligher uses semi-aniline leather, a plywood and hardwood frame and 1.5 density foam.

Is the Valencia worth the extra money?

If you need three seats and want leather that ages well, yes. If you only need two seats in a small room, the $649.00 Galligher covers the job for far less.

Which fits a small living room?

The Galligher. It is 59 inches wide and 37 inches deep. The Valencia is a wide three-seat sofa, so measure your space first.

Which is easier to clean?

The Valencia. Its cushion covers are removable and the leather resists pet scratches. The Galligher's attached cushions can only be spot cleaned.

How do the ratings compare?

The Valencia scores 4.9 out of 5 from 192 ratings. The Galligher scores 3.8 out of 5 from 12 ratings, a much smaller sample.

Valencia Artisan Italian Top Grain Leather Sofa vs Macy's Galligher 59" Leather Loveseat

Buy the Valencia Artisan if you want a full three-seat sofa in Italian top grain leather that ages well and cleans up easily; it is the better long-term piece. Buy the Macy's Galligher if you need a smaller, cheaper loveseat and are fine with semi-aniline leather and attached cushions. The Valencia is $1,599.99 at WoodArtSupply as of November 4, 2026, against $649.00 at Macy's the same day, so the Galligher costs roughly $950 less.

Today the Macy's Galligher 59" Leather Loveseat costs $950.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent