Vans Old Skool Plaid Sneakers vs New Balance 574 Plaid Sneakers

Both are casual plaid-accented sneakers, but they serve different feet and tastes. The Vans Old Skool is a flat, vulcanized skate shoe with a suede upper, padded collar and waffle outsole; the New Balance 574 is a cushioned running-style shoe with an EVA and PU midsole and a wider, more supportive fit. Reviewers consistently praise the 574 for all-day comfort and the Old Skool for durability and clean style. Buy the Vans for looks and skate-grade toughness; buy the 574 if you stand or walk a lot.

• Choose the Vans Old Skool if you want a flat, durable skate silhouette with a suede upper and you like the classic sidestripe look.
• Choose the New Balance 574 if you want a cushioned, supportive shoe for long days on your feet and a roomier fit.