Which is better for making a saddle?

The Saddle Skirting Side. At 10 to 17 oz it has the thickness and firmness saddle skirting needs, and Tandy sells it on its tooling and molding qualities. The Economy side at 3 to 5 oz is far too thin for saddle work.

Both are veg-tan leather, so lifespan depends more on thickness, use, and care than on the product line. The thicker Saddle Skirting Side will resist wear better in straps and saddles. The Economy side is fine for light-duty goods but will stretch and scuff sooner under heavy load.

Is the Saddle Skirting Side worth the extra cost?

Yes if you are making saddles or heavy straps, where thin or inconsistent leather fails. If you are practicing tooling or making small goods, the Economy side does the job for less. No current prices were provided, so compare live listings before deciding.

Can I use the Economy Veg Tan Side for tooling?

Yes. It is veg-tan, so it accepts tooling and dye, but the economy grade has more natural marks and inconsistent firmness. Expect more variation between hides than with the skirting side.

Why is the Saddle Skirting Side rated so low?

It has only one rating, so the 2 out of 5 score reflects a single buyer's experience and is weak evidence. The Economy side has just two ratings at 3.5 out of 5, which is also thin. Read the written reviews for specifics on thickness and defects.

How much leather do I get with each?

The Saddle Skirting Side averages about 21 to 22 sq ft per the listing, though the description says 15 to 20 sq ft. The Economy side averages about 17 to 24 sq ft. Sizes vary by hide, so plan for some spread.

Veg-Tan Saddle Skirting Side Natural vs Tandy Leather Economy Veg Tan Leather Side (3-4 oz)

Buy the Saddle Skirting Side for saddle work, heavy straps, and anything that needs to be tooled, molded, or hold a shape under load. Buy the Economy Veg Tan Side for linings, small goods, practice pieces, and projects where cost matters more than consistency. Both are Tandy Leather veg-tan sides in natural, so the real split is thickness and grade, not tannage. No current prices were provided for either product, so check each store's listing for the latest price before ordering.

Ask our shopping agent