Which is warmer, the Vera Bradley or the Eddie Bauer throw?

The Eddie Bauer has a sherpa reverse, which usually traps more warmth than plain fleece. The Vera Bradley is single-layer fleece and is wider, so it covers more area but insulates less per square inch.

Which throw is better for a Christmas gift?

The Vera Bradley, because its Merry Mischief ornament print is made for the holidays and it comes in an oversized 66-inch width. The Eddie Bauer pine print is more neutral and reads as a year-round gift.

Is the Eddie Bauer throw really only 1 inch wide?

No. A 1-inch width is a listing error; no throw is that size. Confirm the actual dimensions with the store before ordering.

Which one lasts longer?

Both are machine-washable fleece, so care matters more than brand. The Eddie Bauer's 1,200 ratings give more evidence of long-term durability, while the Vera Bradley's 4.9 rating comes from a smaller group of 169 buyers.

Can I use the Eddie Bauer throw in summer?

Yes. The pine print is not holiday-specific, and the fleece side is lighter than the sherpa side, so you can flip it by season.

Is the Vera Bradley worth the extra if it costs more?

Only if you want the oversized width and the Christmas print. If you want a reversible, year-round throw, the Eddie Bauer is the better value at any comparable price.

Vera Bradley Merry Mischief Throw Blanket vs Eddie Bauer Stepped Pines Plush Throw

Both are machine-washable fleece throws, but they serve different shoppers. The Vera Bradley is a 66-inch oversized Christmas throw with an ornament print, best for holiday decorating and gifting. The Eddie Bauer Stepped Pines is a reversible fleece-and-sherpa plush throw with a much larger review base and a more neutral pine print that works year-round. Compare current prices across stores on Deal.ai before you buy, since neither listing gives a price here.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.