Versace Dylan Turquoise Gift Set vs Tocca Mini Fragrance Discovery Set

The Versace Dylan Turquoise set is the better gift: a full eau de toilette spray plus shower gel and body gel in one fresh, summery scent, presented as a set. The Tocca Discovery Set is the better buy for someone who does not yet know their taste, since eight 0.05 oz eau de parfum vials let them try a range of fragrances before committing to a full bottle. Versace wins on presentation and on giving a usable full-size spray; Tocca wins on variety and on sampling. Owners rate the Versace set modestly at 3.9 out of 5, and the Tocca vials are tiny, so expect only a few wears from each.

• Choose the Versace Dylan Turquoise set if you want a ready-to-give gift with a full eau de toilette spray and matching gels in one fresh citrus-and-cedar scent.
• Choose the Tocca Mini Discovery Set if you or the recipient want to sample eight different eau de parfums before buying a full bottle.