Versace Eros Eau de Toilette vs Dolce&Gabbana Light Blue Eau de Toilette

These are two different fragrances for two different wearers, so the choice is mostly about who is wearing it. Eros is a men's aromatic fougère built on mint, green apple and vanilla, and it projects strongly and lasts a long day; owners rate it 4.6 from over 6,000 ratings and call it a cold-weather and evening scent. Light Blue is a women's fresh citrus-floral of Sicilian lemon, apple and cedar, lighter and cleaner, with a huge 4.6 rating base of about 53,000 and a reputation as an easy everyday warm-weather scent. Build and bottle quality are solid on both; Eros is the bolder, heavier scent, Light Blue the safer, more versatile one.

• Choose the Versace Eros if you want a sweet, minty-woody men's scent with strong projection for evenings, cold weather or nights out.
• Choose the Dolce&Gabbana Light Blue if you want a light, fresh lemon-and-apple scent that suits daily wear and warm weather.