Vesteel 12-Piece Stoneware Dinnerware Set vs Mikasa Watercolor Forest 16-Piece Bone China Set

The Mikasa Watercolor Forest is the better choice if you want a full 16-piece set with mugs and a distinctive pine-tree design on bone china. The Vesteel is the better choice if you want thicker, ribbed stoneware that stacks neatly and shrugs off daily wear. Owners of the Mikasa praise the pattern and the lightweight feel, but several note the plates are very thin. The Vesteel has a larger rating base and a sturdier hand feel, but it has no mugs and only 12 pieces.

• Choose the Vesteel if you want durable, stackable stoneware for everyday family meals and don't need mugs.
• Choose the Mikasa if you want a complete 16-piece bone china set with mugs and a pine-tree design that carries into the bowls.