Victrola Automatic Bluetooth Turntable vs Crosley C300 Turntable with S100 Speakers

The C300 is the stronger package. It pairs a fully automatic belt-drive deck with a pair of 120-watt powered speakers, adds fast-forward and rewind controls, and uses the same Audio-Technica ATN3600L cartridge as the Victrola. The Victrola Automatic is simpler and comes in more colors, but owner reports of the auto mechanism failing, the tonearm stopping early, and Bluetooth dropping are common enough to matter. Buy the Victrola if you want a compact all-in-one look and a repeat function; buy the C300 if you want the speakers included and fewer automation complaints.

• Choose the Victrola Automatic if you want a single compact unit with a repeat-side function and a choice of colors, and you mostly play records start to finish.
• Choose the C300 if you want the turntable and speakers as one set, with fast-forward and rewind and a heavier platter for steadier speed.