Vionic Gemma II Women's Slipper vs Orthofeet Charlotte Orthopedic Slipper

Buy the Orthofeet Charlotte if foot pain, plantar fasciitis, bunions or a need for removable orthotic insoles drives the decision. Its anatomical arch support, wide toe box and adjustable strap target those problems directly. The Vionic Gemma II is the better-looking, more structured slipper, with VIO MOTION arch support, a deep heel cup and a 1.4-inch heel, but its 3.8 rating from 601 ratings is middling. The Charlotte scores higher at 4.0 but from only 43 ratings, and owners split: some praise the comfort and durability, others say it runs large and feels cheap with little support.

• Choose the Vionic Gemma II if you want a cushioned, arch-supporting slipper with a low heel and a dressier mule look that works indoors and briefly outdoors.
• Choose the Orthofeet Charlotte if you have plantar fasciitis, bunions or diabetes-related foot needs and want a removable orthotic insole and a wide toe box.