Which is better for a small ice cream shop?

The Advance 581. Its six programs and removable agitators keep output consistent across staff and let you swap agitators between products. The base Mix'n Machine is fine only if you make one product at one texture.

Is the Advance 581 worth the extra cost?

At $939.99 versus $733.09, you pay about $207 more for variable speed, six programs, ten agitators, and auto shut-off. For a commercial kitchen that is a small premium for the added control.

Both are Vitamix commercial units with similar steel and plastic construction. The Advance's removable agitators can be replaced individually, which extends service life; the base model's permanent agitator cannot.

Can either make thick shakes and frozen custard?

Yes. Both are built for thick frozen product, and the base model is rated to run at consistent speed through thin and thick blends. The Advance lets you dial speed down for thicker mixes.

Do they need special installation?

No. Both are corded 120 V countertop units at 24 in tall, 8.3 in deep, and 10 in wide. The Advance draws 1.6 amps.

Which is better for a home kitchen?

Neither is designed for home use. They are commercial frozen-dessert mixers; a home blender is cheaper and easier for occasional soft-serve.

Vitamix Mix'n Machine vs Vitamix Mix'n Machine Advance 581

Both are commercial soft-serve mixers from Vitamix, not home blenders. The Mix'n Machine is the simpler, cheaper unit at $733.09 as of October 30, 2026, with a fixed agitator and one speed. The Mix'n Machine Advance 581 costs $939.99 at Prima Supply as of November 7, 2026, and adds variable speed, six programs, and a removable agitator system. Buy the Advance if you run a shop and need repeatable results across staff. Buy the base model if you want the lowest-cost Vitamix mixer for light, single-product use.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.