Which is better for soft serve?

The On-Counter. Its cone-shaped soft ice cream agitator and pulse function are built for softer, thicker blends. The standard model ships with a hard ice cream agitator.

Which handles hard ice cream better?

The standard Mix'n Machine, which includes the permanent hard ice cream agitator on a single spindle. The On-Counter can take other agitators, but they are optional extras.

Is the On-Counter worth the extra?

It is not extra right now. At $733.09 as of October 30, 2026 it is $14.73 cheaper than the standard model at $747.82 as of November 3, 2026, and it adds pulse and a splash guard.

Do they have the same motor and size?

Yes. Both are 24 inches high, 10 inches wide and 8.3 inches deep, weigh 27 lbs and use a stainless steel housing with a corded 120-volt power source.

Which has a better warranty?

Only the standard model lists one: 1-year parts and labor and 3-year motor base parts. The On-Counter listing states no warranty terms, so confirm coverage before buying.

Can I use one agitator on both machines?

The On-Counter accepts multiple optional agitators, so it can run a hard ice cream agitator too. The standard model is listed with only the hard ice cream agitator.

Vitamix Mix'n Machine Blender vs Vitamix Mix'n Machine Blender

These are the same 24-inch, 27-lb stainless Vitamix Mix'n Machine base; the difference is the agitator and the controls. The On-Counter model adds a cup-activated lever, a pulse function and a soft-serve cone agitator, while the standard model uses a switch and a hard ice cream agitator. The On-Counter is $733.09 as of October 30, 2026, and the standard model is $747.82 as of November 3, 2026, so the more flexible On-Counter is currently the cheaper of the two.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.