Waldlaufer H-Shelly Wide Fit Ankle Boot vs Simmi London Caitlin Chunky Ankle Boots

The Waldlaufer is the better boot for daily wear in cold or wet weather. It uses nappa leather, a warm leather lining, a removable insole and a TPR sole, and it fastens with laces, a zip and a stretch panel for an adjustable fit. The Simmi London Caitlin is a simpler pull-on in synthetic polyurethane with a rubber outsole and no lining or insole detail given. Owners of Waldlaufer wide-fit boots tend to praise the roomy H fit and all-day comfort; the Caitlin is a fashion-led chunky style that suits short wear and easy on-and-off.

• Choose the Waldlaufer if you want a leather, warmly lined wide-fit boot you can adjust with laces and a zip and wear through winter.
• Choose the Simmi London Caitlin if you want a chunky slip-on look you can pull on fast and wear for short trips or nights out.