Which is warmer for winter?

The wantdo. It has down-alternative insulation, a long body and a storm hood. The Amazon Essentials jacket is a light quilted puffer with no stated warmth rating.

Is the Amazon Essentials jacket waterproof?

No. Its taffeta shell is water-repellent, which handles drizzle but not steady rain. The wantdo is rated waterproof to 3000mm.

Is the wantdo worth about $37 more?

Yes if you need a coat for cold, wet weather. If you only want a light layer for mild days, the Amazon Essentials at $19.75 covers that for less.

The Amazon Essentials has an oversized fit through the shoulders, chest and waist. The wantdo is a standard fit, so check its size chart before ordering.

Only the wantdo. It has a removable faux fur storm hood. The Amazon Essentials jacket has no hood.

Which is better for layering?

The Amazon Essentials. Its roomy cut and light weight fit over sweaters, while the wantdo is a bulky outer coat.

wantdo Coats for Women Long Quilted Winter Jacket Waterproof Coat vs Amazon Essentials Women's Oversized-Fit Square Quilted Puffer Jacket with Adjustable Waist, Zip Front, Side Pockets

Buy the wantdo if you need a real winter coat for cold, wet weather: it is long, has a storm hood, 3000mm waterproofing and down-alternative insulation for $56.98 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026. Buy the Amazon Essentials if you want a light, roomy quilted layer for mild days or layering, at $19.75 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026. The price gap is about $37, and it buys warmth and rain protection the Amazon Essentials jacket does not claim.

Today the Amazon Essentials Women's Oversized-Fit Square Quilted Puffer Jacket with Adjustable Waist, Zip Front, Side Pockets costs $37.23 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent