Which removes fluoride?

Only the Waterdrop King Tank lists a fluoride filter, rated up to 1,000 gallons per pair. The Culligan lists ceramic and granular activated carbon, with no fluoride claim.

Which is cheaper to run?

The Waterdrop's carbon filter pair is rated up to 6,000 gallons, far longer than the Culligan's 6-month filter. The Culligan costs much less up front, so the winner depends on how much water you filter and local filter prices.

Do they hold the same amount?

Yes. Both are 2.25-gallon gravity dispensers, so capacity is not a reason to pick one.

Is the Waterdrop worth about $195 more?

Only if you need fluoride reduction or want to change filters rarely. If you just want basic gravity filtration, the Culligan does the job for far less.

Which has more buying options?

The Culligan. Six stores price it new as of November 6, 2026, against one store for the Waterdrop.

Which is easier to place on a counter?

The Culligan's dimensions are listed at 8.6" wide and 26" tall and 4.54 kg. The Waterdrop's footprint and weight are not listed, so measure your space before ordering it.

Waterdrop King Tank vs Culligan Gravity with MaxClear

Buy the Culligan Gravity with MaxClear if you want a low-cost countertop gravity filter and can accept a 6-month filter swap. Buy the Waterdrop King Tank if you want long filter life and fluoride removal and will pay for it. As of November 6, 2026, the Culligan is $44.96 at eBay and the Waterdrop is $239.99 at Amazon, a gap of about $195.

Today the Culligan Gravity with MaxClear costs $195.03 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.