Which is better for searing steak?

The Weber Genesis E-325s. Its sear zone is the hottest in its line, and the Napoleon Rogue 525 uses standard main burners with no dedicated sear zone.

Which has more cooking room?

The Napoleon has 4 burners and a 56 in wide body, so it spreads heat across more grate area. The Weber has 3 burners but adds an expandable top grate for sides.

Do I need a gas line for either?

Only the Weber can run on natural gas. The Napoleon Rogue 525 is propane only, so you need a tank.

Is the Napoleon worth the extra money?

Yes if you want a side burner and rotisserie. At $539.40 it costs more than the Weber's $489.30 low, but less than the Weber's $849.00 high.

Which is easier to cook a whole chicken on?

The Napoleon, because the rotisserie is included. The Weber has a smoker but no rotisserie listed.

Which holds its price better?

The Napoleon. It moved only from $539.40 to $563.40 since November 1, while the Weber ranged from $489.30 to $849.00.

Weber Genesis E-325s Gas Grill vs Napoleon Rogue 525 Gas Grill

Buy the Weber Genesis E-325s if you want the hottest sear zone and a big prep-and-serve table, and you can use natural gas. Buy the Napoleon Rogue 525 if you want four burners, a side burner and a rotisserie for the same money. The Weber has swung between $489.30 and $849.00 since November 1, so its current price matters more than its list price. The Napoleon has held steady between $539.40 and $563.40, so there is little reason to wait for a drop.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.