Which is better for a large family?

The West Bend Classic. Its 12-cup capacity and automatic keep warm cover a full breakfast without a second pot.

Is the Farberware worth the savings?

Yes if you brew eight cups or fewer. At $23.99 versus $49.99, it costs less than half and takes less counter space.

Which keeps coffee hot longer?

The West Bend, because its keep warm mode holds temperature automatically. The Farberware relies on stovetop heat you control.

Which is easier to clean?

Both list dishwasher-safe parts. The West Bend's basket and stem are removable; the Farberware is fully immersible with a permanent filter basket.

Do either need paper filters?

No. Both use permanent filter baskets, so you skip paper filters.

The West Bend's electric brewing is quicker for a full pot. The Farberware percolates about one cup per minute.

West Bend Classic 12-Cup Percolator vs Farberware 8-Cup Electric Percolator

Buy the West Bend Classic if you need 12 cups and want an electric percolator that keeps coffee warm on the counter. Buy the Farberware 8-Cup if you brew smaller batches and want to spend less. As of November 6, 2026, the West Bend is $49.99 at Home Depot and the Farberware is $23.99 at The Home Depot.

Today the Farberware 8-Cup Electric Percolator costs $26.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.