Whip It 5X Butane 12ct Box vs WHIP-IT! Premium Butane 420ML
Buy the 5X 12ct box if you want the lower-cost, lighter-grade can for refilling everyday lighters. Buy the Premium 420ML case if you need the larger can, the higher refinement claim and the listed safety certifications. The 5X box is the cheaper per-can option of the two, while the Premium case carries the bigger cans and the certification list.
Ask our shopping agent
Whip It 5X Butane 12ct Box
Choose the Whip It 5X 12ct Box if you refill standard lighters often and want the smaller 300ml can at the lower price per can.
Pros
- Lower price per can than the Premium case.
- Lighter case at 6.15 lbs, easier to store and carry.
- Five assorted adapters cover common lighter fill valves.
- 300ml cans suit lighters with small tanks.
Cons
- Smaller 300ml cans need refilling sooner.
- No listed safety certifications.
- 5X refinement is below the Premium grade.
What separates them
| Whip It 5X Butane 12ct Box | WHIP-IT! Premium Butane 420ML | |
|---|---|---|
| Can capacity | 300ml per can | 420ml per can |
| Refinement | 5X refined | Premium, stated zero impurities |
| Cans per case | 12 | 12 |
| Case weight | 6.15 lbs | 8 lbs |
| Fill tip and adapters | Metal fill tip, five assorted adapters | Five tip adapters |
| Stated certifications | None listed | ISO 9001, TUV, EN-417 |
| Odor | Not stated | Non-odorized above 150ml |
| Price per can | Lower |
Price history
- Whip It 5X Butane 12ct Box: lowest $34.88 on Oct 30 at Amazon.
- WHIP-IT! Premium Butane 420ML: lowest $5.75 on Oct 30 at BVV.
Prices at every store
Whip It 5X Butane 12ct Box
- Yatin EnterprisesCheck price at Yatin Enterprises
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
WHIP-IT! Premium Butane 420ML
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Consumers Wine & SpiritsCheck price at Consumers Wine & Spirits
- BVVCheck price at BVV
Specs compared
| Spec | Whip It 5X Butane 12ct Box | WHIP-IT! Premium Butane 420ML |
|---|---|---|
| Volume per Can | 300ml | — |
| Refinement Level | 5X refined | — |
| Packaging | 12 cans per display pack | — |
| Fill Tip | metal fill tip | — |
| Included Adapters | five assorted adapters | — |
| Display Weight | 6.150 lbs | — |
| Rec. Use | Lighter | — |
| number_of_pieces | — | 12 |
| size | — | 12 |
| Item weight | — | 1.36 kg |
| Unit count |
What reviewers say
WHIP-IT! Premium Butane 420ML
Torch and lighter owners generally rate WHIP-IT! as a clean-burning butane that lights reliably and leaves little residue. Complaints center on shipping limits and on cans arriving with bent or leaking nozzles.
Pros
- Burns clean with little soot or jet clogging
- Refills lighters and torches quickly
- Adapters fit a wide range of valves
- Good value per can in the 12-pack
Cons
- Some cans arrive dented or leaking
- Ground-only shipping slows delivery
- Nozzle fit can be loose on some lighters
- California retail restrictions limit where it can be bought
Questions and answers
- Which is better for refilling a standard lighter?
- The 5X box. Its 300ml cans and five adapters fit common lighter valves, and it costs less per can. The Premium cans work too but cost more.
- Is the Premium butane worth the extra money?
- If you want the larger 420ml can and the listed ISO 9001, TUV and EN-417 certifications, yes. For plain lighter refills the 5X box does the job for less.
- How much more gas is in the Premium can?
- 40% more. The Premium can holds 420ml against 300ml in the 5X can, so a case holds about 1.4 liters more in total.
- Which case is easier to store?
- The 5X box. It weighs 6.15 lbs against 8 lbs for the Premium case, and its cans are smaller.
- Can either be shipped fast?
- The Premium case ships ground only and does not go to Hawaii, Puerto Rico or other US territories. Check shipping terms on the 5X box before ordering.
- Does the Premium butane have an odor?
- It is listed as non-odorized in quantities above 150ml. California restricts retail sale of non-odorized butane above that size.