Whirlpool 25 Cu. Ft. 4-Door French Door Refrigerator vs Maytag MRFF5036PZ French Door Refrigerator

Both are 36-inch full-depth French door refrigerators with water dispensers and ENERGY STAR ratings, so the choice comes down to layout and ice. The Whirlpool is the better pick if you want an in-door ice maker with a large 3.7 lb ice capacity and a refrigerated exterior drawer for snacks and drinks. The Maytag is the better pick if you want more freezer room, a full-width crisper for bulk produce, and a 10-year limited parts warranty on the compressor. Owners rate the Whirlpool 4.2 out of 5 across about 1,000 ratings, with common praise for the fingerprint-resistant finish and complaints about noise and dispenser quirks.

• Choose the Whirlpool if you want in-door ice with high capacity, a refrigerated exterior drawer, and measured water fill at the dispenser.
• Choose the Maytag if freezer space, a full-width crisper for large items, and a long compressor parts warranty matter more than in-door ice.