Whirlpool French Door Refrigerator vs LG Counter-Depth Max French Door Refrigerator

Buy the LG if fitting flush with your cabinets matters most: it is counter-depth and still holds 27 cu. ft., more than the Whirlpool's 25.2 cu. ft. despite being shallower. The Whirlpool is the safer pick if you want a standard-depth fridge with a proven track record; its 4.3 rating from about 11,000 owners is strong, and Whirlpool's French door line is widely regarded as reliable and easy to service. The LG adds a door alarm and an internal water and ice dispenser, while the Whirlpool puts its dispenser on the door and uses a single evaporator, which is simpler but can share odors between fridge and freezer.

• Choose the Whirlpool if you have full-depth cabinet space, want a door-mounted water dispenser, and value a long, well-reviewed reliability record over a flush fit.
• Choose the LG if you want a counter-depth fridge that still holds a large load, plus a door alarm and an internal dispenser that keeps the front clean.