Sharicks 91-in Tall Wooden Bookcase vs Martin Furniture Avondale 94-Inch Bookcase

The Martin Furniture Avondale is the sturdier, better-finished tall bookcase, with real wood and veneers, a weathered two-tone finish and adjustable shelves. The Sharicks unit is a narrow particle-board tower that is meant to attach to a Murphy bed, and its own listing gives conflicting heights and widths. Buy the Avondale if you want a freestanding bookcase that looks good and lasts. Buy the Sharicks only if you need a slim 13-inch-wide filler beside a Murphy bed and accept MDF construction.

• Choose the Sharicks 91-in bookcase if you need a very narrow tower to sit flush against a Murphy bed in a small room.
• Choose the Martin Furniture Avondale if you want a freestanding, solid-wood bookcase with adjustable shelves and a weathered finish.