Whynter 7-in-1 Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker vs Nostalgia Professional 1.25 Qt Soft Serve Ice Cream Machine

Buy the Whynter if you want one machine that does soft serve plus slushies, cocktails and frozen coffee, and you want to skip pre-freezing. Buy the Nostalgia if soft serve is the whole job and you want more texture control and a faster first batch. The Whynter's built-in compressor is the bigger engineering story and its 1.6-quart bowl holds more; the Nostalgia counters with 10 thickness settings and a 17-minute ready time. Owners of compressor machines like the Whynter praise the no-pre-freeze convenience but note the 24.6 lb footprint and 55 dB hum; Nostalgia buyers like the lever dispensing and easy cleaning mode.

• Choose the Whynter if you want soft serve and slushies from one countertop machine without freezing a bowl overnight.
• Choose the Nostalgia if soft serve is all you need and you want finer texture control and a quicker batch.