Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard vs Northern White Cedar Log King Headboard

Buy the Willowton if you want a wide, low-cost whitewashed headboard that fits a California king and you accept a laminate finish over engineered wood. Buy the cedar log headboard if you want solid domestic wood, real log character and a taller 60-inch profile. The Willowton is the cheaper, easier-to-match piece; the cedar is the longer-lasting, more distinctive one.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Signature Design by Ashley
Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard

Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard

Choose the Willowton if you want a shabby-chic whitewashed panel headboard for a king or California king bed at the lowest cost and don't mind engineered wood.

Pros
  • Fits both king and California king, so it works with either frame you own
  • Whitewashed faux plank look suits beach cottage and shabby-chic rooms
Light at 82 lbs and quick to assemble
  • Lowest-cost way to get a panel headboard in this style
  • Cons
    • Engineered wood and laminate, not solid wood
    • Hardware not included, so check your frame bolts
    • Assembly required
    • Faux finish can chip or peel at edges over time
    N
    Northern White Cedar Log King Headboard

    Northern White Cedar Log King Headboard

    Choose the Northern White Cedar log headboard if you want solid US-made wood, a 60-inch height and a rustic log look that will hold up for decades.

    Pros
    • Solid Northern white cedar, a wood that resists rot and insects
    • Made in the USA with attention to joinery
    • Taller 60-inch profile gives more visual presence
    • Real log character that ages instead of peeling
    Cons
    • King size only, so it won't fit a California king frame
    • Solid cedar costs more than a laminate panel
    • Heavier and harder to move alone
    • Log style is a strong look that won't suit every bedroom

    What separates them

    Willowton King/California King Panel HeadboardNorthern White Cedar Log King Headboard
    MaterialEngineered wood (MDF/particleboard) with decorative laminateSolid Northern white cedar wood
    FinishWhitewash replicated worn-through paint over faux plank patternNatural cedar, no replicated finish
    Height53.66 in60 in
    Width80.91 in, fits king and California kingKing size only
    OriginImportedMade in the USA
    AssemblyRequired, about 5 minutes; hardware not includedLog construction with attention to joinery
    Weight82 lbsNot listed; solid cedar is heavier per inch
    StyleShabby chic, beach cottage, faux plankRustic log cabin

    Price history

    • Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard: lowest $374.12 on Oct 31 at Amazon.
    • Northern White Cedar Log King Headboard: lowest $1,160.99 on Oct 31 at Wayfair.

    Prices at every store

    Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard

    • John V Schultz FurnitureCheck price at John V Schultz Furniture
    • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
    • JMD FurnitureCheck price at JMD Furniture
    Prices and history →

    Northern White Cedar Log King Headboard

    • WayfairCheck price at Wayfair
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecWillowton King/California King Panel HeadboardNorthern White Cedar Log King Headboard
    Height53.66"60 in high
    Materialengineered wood (MDF/particleboard) and decorat…Wood
    Width80.91"—
    Depth3.23"—
    Weight82.00 lbs (37.19 kgs)—
    FinishWhitewash replicated worn through paint—
    PatternReplicated wood grained block pattern—
    HardwareHardware not included—
    AssemblyAssembly required—
    Assembly time5 Minutes—
    Bed sizeCalifornia King—
    Made in the USA—Proudly manufactured domestically with attentio…
    Show all 13 specsShow fewer specs
    SpecWillowton King/California King Panel HeadboardNorthern White Cedar Log King Headboard
    Size—King

    What reviewers say

    Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard

    Owners of the Willowton collection generally like the whitewashed finish and say it looks more expensive than the price. Common complaints center on the engineered wood build, hardware and assembly issues, and finish that can chip.

    Pros
    • Attractive whitewashed finish for the money
    • Sturdy once assembled
    • Matches other Willowton pieces
    Cons
    • Particleboard and laminate feel
    • Missing or poor-quality hardware reported
    • Finish can chip or arrive damaged

    Questions and answers

    Which is better for a California king bed?
    The Willowton. It is listed as king/California king at 80.91 inches wide. The cedar headboard is king only, so check your frame width before buying it.
    Which lasts longer?
    The cedar log headboard. Solid Northern white cedar holds up outdoors-grade well and resists rot and insects. The Willowton is particleboard with a laminate skin, which can chip at corners and edges.
    Is the cedar headboard worth the extra money?
    If you want solid domestic wood and a 60-inch height, yes. If you want a whitewashed look on a budget and need California king fit, the Willowton does the job for less.
    Do either need assembly?
    The Willowton needs assembly, listed at about 5 minutes, and hardware is not included. The cedar headboard is built with joinery; confirm mounting hardware with the seller.
    Will the Willowton match white or gray bedroom furniture?
    It is a whitewash over a replicated wood-grain plank pattern, so it reads warm off-white. It pairs best with white, cream and light wood pieces, less so with dark espresso sets.
    Which is heavier?
    The Willowton is 82 lbs. Solid cedar at 60 inches tall will weigh more; plan for two people to move and mount it.

    More comparisons

    • Willowton King/California King Panel Headboard vs Lettner King/California King Panel Headboard
    • Lettner King/California King Panel Headboard vs Northern White Cedar Log King Headboard