Winco 602 Madison Round Chafer vs Sterno Buffet Kit 70370

Buy the Winco 602 if you host recurring buffets and want a durable, good-looking chafer that will last for years. Buy the Sterno 70370 kit if you need a complete, disposable-pan setup for a one-off event or occasional use. The Winco is heavier-gauge 18/10 stainless with a roll-top lid and reusable pans; the Sterno is aluminum with a folding wire rack, two half-size pans and gel fuel. Owners of roll-top stainless chafers praise the smooth lid and easy cleaning, while Sterno kit users like the all-in-one convenience but note the thin aluminum pans dent and the rack feels light.

• Choose the Winco 602 if you cater regularly, want a reusable mirror-finish chafer and prefer a roll-top lid that opens to 90 or 180 degrees.
• Choose the Sterno 70370 if you want a self-contained buffet kit with pans, fuel and utensils for a single event or light occasional use.