Which is better for wearing over boots?

The wide-leg pair. Its roughly 10 in. leg opening drapes over boots and shoes. The straight leg is the better choice if you tuck jeans into boots.

Is the wide leg worth the extra $6.20?

Only if you want the wider leg and front pockets. Fabric, waistband and care are the same, so the straight leg at $28.79 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026 is the better value otherwise.

Which has the better size range for short or tall shoppers?

The straight leg. It adds a Petite Short 25 in. inseam on top of Average, Petite and Tall. The wide leg offers Average, Petite and Tall only.

Do either of these jeans have back pockets?

No. Both have a smooth, pocketless back. The wide leg adds flat slant front pockets; the straight leg has no front pockets either.

Which holds up longer?

Both use the same cotton/poly/spandex blend and machine wash care, so wear should be similar. Some wide-leg reviewers say the fabric changed for the worse, which is a point against it.

Which rise is more comfortable?

The straight leg sits high above the waist; the wide leg sits mid rise at about 12 in. Choose based on whether you prefer a high waistband under tunics or a lower one.

Woman Within Plus Size Fineline Pull-On Elastic Waist Straight-Leg Stretch Denim Jeans vs Woman Within Plus Size Fineline Stretch Denim Wide-Leg Pull-On Jeans

Both are pull-on Fineline jeans from Woman Within with the same cotton/poly/spandex fabric and elastic waistband. The straight-leg pair is the cheaper buy at $28.79 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026, against $34.99 at Target for the wide-leg pair. Pick the straight leg for a slim, tunic-friendly line and the wide leg for a roomier leg that covers shoes.

Today the Woman Within Plus Size Fineline Pull-On Elastic Waist Straight-Leg Stretch Denim Jeans costs $6.20 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.