Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Pima Clara. Its cotton jersey is breathable and the ruffled sleeves are short. The DayBasics is polyester, though it is lightweight and described as breathable.

Which one covers more of the arm?

The DayBasics. Its 3/4 sleeves run 18.5–20.5 inches and cover the upper arm. The Clara has short ruffled sleeves.

Is the Pima Clara worth the extra money?

If you want natural Pima cotton, a dressier A-line cut, and back elastic, yes. If you mainly want an inexpensive gown for sleeping, the DayBasics does the job for $43.45.

The Clara runs large for some shoppers, who size down. The DayBasics lists a chest width of 19–29 inches across S to XXXL, so check the size chart before ordering.

Will either one shrink?

The Clara shrinks 3–5% when washed; machine wash cold and dry without heat. The DayBasics is described as keeping its shape wash after wash.

Which has more size options?

The DayBasics, which comes in S to XXXL. The Clara's listing does not state a size range.

Cool-jams DayBasics Long Scoop Neck Nightgown vs Petite Plume Pima Clara Nightgown

Buy the Cool-jams DayBasics if you want an inexpensive, low-maintenance sleep gown with 3/4 sleeves and full below-the-knee coverage. Buy the Petite Plume Pima Clara if you want breathable Pima cotton, a dressier A-line midi look, and don't mind paying roughly 2.7 times more. As of November 7, 2026, the DayBasics is $43.45 at Cool-jams Wicking Sleepwear and the Clara is $118.00 at Nordstrom.

Today the Cool-jams DayBasics Long Scoop Neck Nightgown costs $74.55 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.