Women's Madi Insulated Slip-On Mules vs Steve Madden Women's Rafe
Buy the Hunter Madi if you need a warm, water-resistant shoe for cold, wet days. Buy the Steve Madden Rafe if you want a lightweight leather loafer for office and summer wear. The Madi is $108.99 at eBay as of November 3, 2026. The Rafe's price was not provided, so compare it at checkout.
Ask our shopping agent
Women's Madi Insulated Slip-On Mules
4.7$108.99at eBayObserved at 9:24 AM
Choose the Madi if you want an insulated, water-resistant slip-on with a lugged outsole for cold and wet weather.
Pros
- Insulated fleece lining for cold days
- Water-resistant upper
- Lugged outsole grips wet, uneven ground
- Bungee toggle adjusts the fit
- 4.7 of 5 from 73 ratings
Cons
- Textile outsole wears faster than rubber
- Faux fur lining can get warm indoors
- Not a dressy look
What separates them
| Women's Madi Insulated Slip-On Mules | Steve Madden Women's Rafe | |
|---|---|---|
| Upper material | Quilted textile | Leather, suede and nylon |
| Lining | Faux fur | Leather |
| Weather protection | Water resistant and insulated | Not described as water resistant |
| Outsole | Chunky lugged textile outsole | Rubber outsole |
| Weight | Not stated | 5.6 ounces |
| Closure | Slip-on with bungee toggle | Backless slip-on |
| Best use season | Cooler days | Summer |
| Rating | 4.7 of 5 from 73 ratings | 4.2 of 5 from 74 ratings |
Price history
- Women's Madi Insulated Slip-On Mules: lowest $108.99 on Nov 3 at eBay.
- Steve Madden Women's Rafe: lowest $65.40 on Nov 2 at Nordstrom.
Prices at every store
Women's Madi Insulated Slip-On Mules
- eBayNew
In stockSold by ela-9385
$108.99Free shippingObserved at 9:24 AM - Hunter BootsNew
In stockReturn policy
$110.00Observed at 9:23 AM - DICK'S Sporting GoodsNew
In stock
$125.00+ $9.99 shippingObserved at 7:32 AM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
$124.93Free shippingObserved at 7:32 AM
Specs compared
| Spec | Women's Madi Insulated Slip-On Mules | Steve Madden Women's Rafe |
|---|---|---|
| Outsole material | Textile | Rubber Outsole |
| Lining material | Faux fur | Leather |
| Heel height range | Low | — |
| Heel type | Flat | — |
| Toe type | Round | — |
| Closure | Slip-on | — |
| Upper material | Textile | — |
| Sock material | Textile | — |
| Shaft height | 0.0 | — |
| Calf circumference | 0.0 | — |
| Width | — |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for winter?
- The Madi. It is insulated, water resistant and has a lugged outsole for wet, cold ground. The Rafe is a summer loafer with no insulation.
- Which is lighter?
- The Rafe, at 5.6 ounces. Hunter does not list a weight for the Madi, but its chunky outsole and lining make it the heavier shoe.
- Which has better traction?
- The Madi's chunky lugged outsole is built for wet pavement and uneven paths. The Rafe has a flat rubber outsole meant for indoor and dry wear.
- Is the Madi worth $108.99?
- It is the only one of the two with insulation and water resistance, so the price buys weather protection. If you only need a dry-weather loafer, the Rafe covers that for less.
- Can I wear the Rafe to the office?
- Yes. The leather upper and round toe suit office wear. The backless design is casual, so check your dress code.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Rafe's rubber outsole and leather upper should outlast the Madi's textile outsole. The Madi's fleece lining also compresses with heavy use.