Lands' End Squall 3-in-1 Parka vs Patagonia Tres Down 3-in-1 Parka

The Lands' End Squall is the warmer, more protective pick for real winter cold and wet, with a waterproof sealed-seam shell and a heavier synthetic liner. The Patagonia Tres is the better travel and hiking coat: lighter, breathable, and its recycled down liner packs smaller. Build quality favors Patagonia's H2No shell and down, but the Squall's synthetic fill keeps working when damp and costs far less for the same three-in-one idea.

• Choose the Lands' End Squall if you face freezing rain, deep cold, or slush and want a fully waterproof shell with a warm synthetic liner that still insulates when wet.
• Choose the Patagonia Tres if you hike, travel, or want a lighter, breathable coat with packable down and a removable hood.