Striped Cropped Knit Vest with Gold Buttons vs Scoop Mockneck Sweater Vest

The Scoop vest is the safer pick for most shoppers: a stretchy, seamless polyester-viscose knit in sizes XS to 4X, with a ribbed mock neck that reads more polished at work. The striped Kohl's vest is the better warm-weather layer, with a lighter acetate-lyocell blend, a V-neck that vents heat and a cropped cut that sits well over dresses and high-waist pants. Build is close on both; the Kohl's piece claims pilling resistance and holds shape at the ribbed hem, while the Scoop leans on stretch and easy machine care.

• Choose the striped Kohl's vest if you want a light, breathable V-neck layer for air-conditioned offices and warm days, and you like the preppy striped look.
• Choose the Scoop mockneck vest if you want a stretchy, seamless knit with a higher neckline and the widest size range, including plus.