ScarletteEmmy Suede Platform Mules vs Dr. Martens Suede Slingback Platform Mules

The Dr. Martens is the better-built shoe: real suede, a leather lining and a 1-inch platform on a rubber and EVA sole, backed by a brand with a long track record. The ScarletteEmmy is the more adjustable and more forgiving fit, with a hook-and-loop back strap and a contoured EVA footbed, but its listing mixes artificial leather and suede claims and it has only 11 ratings. Buy the Dr. Martens if you want a durable everyday platform mule; buy the ScarletteEmmy if you need a secure, wide-friendly strap fit and slip-on ease.

• Choose the ScarletteEmmy if you want an adjustable hook-and-loop back strap, a medium width and a contoured footbed for all-day slip-on wear.
• Choose the Dr. Martens if you want genuine suede with a leather lining and a proven platform sole that holds up to daily use.