Wrangler Men's Leather Belt with Removable Buckle vs Marshal Wallet Full Grain Leather Dress Belt

The Marshal Wallet belt is the better buy for most shoppers. Its full-grain leather is denser and more moisture-resistant than the Wrangler's leather, and it ages into a patina rather than cracking. The Wrangler is wider at 1.5 inches and comes in brown, so it suits jeans and casual wear better. Owners of both report the removable buckles hold up, but full-grain construction generally outlasts the Wrangler's leather over years of daily use.

• Choose the Wrangler if you want a wider 1.5-inch brown belt for jeans and casual outfits, and you prefer a Western-leaning look.
• Choose the Marshal Wallet if you want a slimmer 1.25-inch black belt in full-grain leather that works with dress pants, suits and jeans alike.