Xtratuf Men's Ankle Deck Boot vs Xtratuf Men's Full Grain Leather Ankle Deck Boot

Both are waterproof slip-on deck boots from Xtratuf. The rubber Ankle Deck Boot is the better wet-work boot: fully rubber, easy to hose off, and reviewers call it possibly the most comfortable rain boot they tested. The Leather Ankle Deck Boot trades that for a full grain leather upper that looks at home on a night out and resists salt water, with an EVA insole and midsole for all-day standing. Owners of the rubber version report a wide, loose fit, so size with that in mind.

• Choose the Xtratuf Ankle Deck Boot if you want a hose-off rubber boot for fishing, decks and muddy weather that doubles as an everyday slip-on.
• Choose the Xtratuf Full Grain Leather Ankle Deck Boot if you want the same waterproof deck sole in a leather boot you can wear to dinner or on the ranch.