Which is better for a long-lasting scent?

The YSL Libre set. It is an eau de parfum with lavender and orange blossom, which lasts longer on skin than the Jo Malone colognes. The Jo Malone set is cologne strength and needs reapplying.

Which is better as a gift?

The Jo Malone set suits someone who likes trying scents, since five colognes let them explore and layer. The YSL set suits someone with a clear taste for bold florals who also wants a mascara.

Is the YSL set worth the lower price?

Yes, if you want one signature scent. At $85.00 at eBay as of November 3, 2026, you get 60 ml of eau de parfum plus a mascara, against $106.25 at Macy's for 45 ml of cologne.

Can I layer the Jo Malone scents?

Yes. The set is built for wearing each cologne alone or layering two for a custom finish. The YSL set is a single fragrance and is not meant for mixing.

Which has more perfume in total?

The YSL set, with 60 ml across the 50 ml bottle and 10 ml spray. The Jo Malone set holds 45 ml across five 9 ml bottles.

Is either set returnable?

The YSL set cannot be returned for hygiene reasons unless faulty. Check the Jo Malone seller's return policy before buying, since opened fragrance is often restricted.

Yves Saint Laurent Libre Eau de Parfum Gift Set vs Jo Malone London Cologne Collection Gift Set

Buy the YSL Libre set for a single bold floral signature scent plus a mascara, at $85 at eBay as of November 3, 2026. Buy the Jo Malone Cologne Collection for variety and layering, at $106.25 at Macy's as of November 3, 2026. The YSL set costs about $21 less and gives a full 50 ml bottle plus a 10 ml travel spray. The Jo Malone set gives five 9 ml colognes and no full-size bottle.

Today the Yves Saint Laurent Libre Eau de Parfum Gift Set costs $21.25 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent