Is the Caraway baking sheet really non-stick?

Yes, it has a ceramic non-stick coating. Owners report easy release, though some say it weakens with heavy use.

Is it dishwasher safe?

Caraway generally advises hand washing ceramic-coated bakeware to protect the coating. Check the care card that comes with the sheet.

It is a standard cookie sheet built to fit common oven racks. Confirm the exact dimensions on the listing before buying.

Does it work with metal utensils?

Better to avoid them. Metal tools can scratch the ceramic coating and shorten its non-stick life.

Is it worth it over a plain aluminum sheet?

You pay for the ceramic coating and the Caraway name. A plain aluminum sheet costs less but needs more oil or parchment.

You pay for the ceramic coating and the Caraway name. Compare it with other ceramic sheets and with plain aluminum sheets, which need more oil or parchment.

All Travel Tech Clothes Shoes Jewelry Home Beauty Outdoors Toys

This hour's deals

−66%

Home · Rebel

The baking sheet your cookies deserve

Name: Caraway Ceramic Baking Sheet
Brand: Caraway
Availability: InStock

Caraway Ceramic Baking Sheet

Caraway's ceramic baking sheet for home bakers who want even browning and easy cleanup.

Deal score 8.4 · Steal

$21.99$65.00 Rebel's regular price

You save $43.01 at Rebel

Deal.ai's agents found this deal on November 10. The store may have changed its price since.

Why it's a great deal

Elsewhere right now: Sur La Table $42.00, Macy's $46.00, Target $55.00, and 1 more (typical $50.50 across 4 stores)
Cheaper than all 4 other stores selling it right now
Rebel lists its regular price at $65.00: 66% off by its own figures
Rated 4.8 out of 5 by 9,100 buyers

Visit Rebel

Every store we checked

RebelNew
In stock
$21.99Checked 44 min ago
Visit Rebel
The Home DepotNew
In stock
$45.00Free shippingChecked 43 min ago
Visit The Home Depot
Crate & BarrelNew
In stock
$55.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit Crate & Barrel
TargetNew
In stock
$55.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit Target
Sur La TableNew
Availability unknown
$42.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit Sur La Table
CarawayNew
Availability unknown
$45.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit Caraway
Macy'sNew
Availability unknown
$46.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit Macy's
Grove CollaborativeNew
Availability unknown
$46.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit Grove Collaborative
Bloomingdale'sNew
Availability unknown
$46.00Checked Nov 6
Visit Bloomingdale's
WayfairNew
Availability unknown
$50.00Checked Nov 6
Visit Wayfair
The Container StoreNew
Availability unknown
$55.00Checked 44 min ago
Visit The Container Store
NordstromNew
Availability unknown
$55.00Checked Nov 6
Visit Nordstrom
WalmartNew
Availability unknown
$55.00Checked Nov 6
Visit Walmart
west elmNew
Availability unknown
$65.00Checked Nov 6
Visit west elm

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Price history and every store's price →

Reading Rebel’s product page for the details…

Specs

Material: Aluminum
Non-Stick: Yes
Type: Cookie Sheet
Temperature (max) (°F): 550.0Source
Color: GraySource
Features: Handwash, Non-stick CoatingSource

About the Caraway Ceramic Baking Sheet

The Caraway Ceramic Baking Sheet is an aluminum cookie sheet with a ceramic non-stick coating, sold as part of Caraway's ceramic bakeware line. It is aimed at cooks who want a non-stick sheet without PTFE. It is a single sheet rather than a set, so it suits buyers replacing one pan or adding to a Caraway collection. Owners rate it highly for even browning and easy release, though some report the coating fades with heavy use.

Best forHome bakers who avoid PTFE coatingsBuying a single replacement sheetGift buyers adding to a Caraway setEveryday cookies, sheet-pan dinners and roasted vegetables

Pros

Ceramic non-stick coating instead of PTFE
Aluminum body heats evenly and resists warping
Wipes clean without heavy scrubbing
Fits standard oven racks as a cookie sheet

Cons

Ceramic coatings lose their release over time

More deals like this