Are these real diamonds and real gold?

Yes. The listing specifies diamond stones in 14k white gold, so the metal is solid 14k, not plated.

What does P2–P3 clarity mean for how they look?

P2–P3 maps to I2–I3 on the GIA scale, the lowest graded range. Inclusions are typically visible without a loupe, and the stones may look cloudy next to higher-clarity diamonds.

Is $551.70 a good price?

It is the only new price listed as of November 8, 2026, so there is nothing to compare it to. For 1.5 carats of diamond in 14k gold, it is inexpensive, but the low clarity is why.

How big are the earrings?

Each stud is about 0.25 inches wide and 0.25 inches tall. The 1.5 carats are split across two stones, so each is roughly 0.75 carat.

Do they come with a diamond certificate?

No grading report is listed. At this clarity grade, independent certification is uncommon, so ask Macy's for the specifics before buying.

When is the best time to buy?

Macy's runs frequent fine jewelry sales, and diamond studs are a common holiday and Mother's Day promotion item. Watch the price history for a drop below $551.70.

All Travel Tech Clothes Shoes Jewelry Home Beauty Outdoors Toys

This hour's deals

−71%

Jewelry · Macy's

Diamond earrings ready for the spotlight

Name: Macy's Women's Diamond Earrings
Brand: Macy's
Availability: InStock

Macy's Women's Diamond Earrings

Macy's women's diamond earrings, an easy fine-jewelry upgrade for someone who loves a little shine.

Deal score 10.0 · Unreal

$551.70$1,895.90 Macy's regular price

You save $1,344.20 at Macy's

This deal was in an earlier drop. The store may have changed its price since.

Why it's a great deal

Macy's lists its regular price at $1,895.90: 71% off by its own figures

Visit Macy's

Every store we checked

Macy'sNew
In stock
$551.70Observed at 1:03 PM
Visit Macy's

Price history and every store's price →

Reading Macy's’s product page for the details…

Specs

Earrings: Stud EarringsSource
Karat: 14kSource
Carat (Smaller stones): 1.5Source
Stone Color: TransparentSource
Color: SilverSource
Material: White GoldSource
Gender: FemaleSource
Stone: DiamondSource
Width ("): 0.25Source
Diamond Clarity: P3 (I3), P2 (I2)Source

About the Macy's Women's Diamond Earrings

These are 14k white gold stud earrings from Macy's set with two diamonds totaling 1.5 carats. The stones are clarity-graded P2–P3 (I2–I3), the low end of the scale, so expect visible inclusions and a warm-to-bright look rather than a clean white sparkle. Each earring measures about a quarter inch across. The best new price is $551.70 at Macy's as of November 8, 2026, and only one store lists them new, so there is no cheaper alternative to compare against.

Best forShoppers who want a large diamond look for under $600Gift buyers who want 14k gold rather than plated metalEveryday stud wearers who don't mind included stonesPeople buying from Macy's directly, since no other store lists them

Pros

14k white gold setting, not plated or gold-filled
Two diamonds totaling 1.5 carats, a big look for the price
Classic four-prong stud style that works daily or dressed up
About $552 is low for 1.5 carats of diamond in 14k gold

Cons

More deals like this