StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Allen Edmonds › Oxford
Allen Edmonds
Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford

4.4(2,800 ratings)

Best price now

$99.99at WhatnotChecked Nov 21
Deal: 45% off at Allen Edmonds →

Compared across 17 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Finding cheaper alternatives

Checking the Deal.ai store…

Price facts

  • Last seen at $99.99 at Whatnot on Nov 21.
  • It's up $50.00 from $49.99 a week ago.
  • Since Oct 30 it has ranged from $49.99 to $270.00.
  • Checked at 17 stores.
$99.99at WhatnotChecked Nov 21
Visit Whatnot

Our take on the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford

The Fifth Avenue is Allen Edmonds' cap-toe balmoral oxford, handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin from European calfskin with brogue detailing and a 360° Goodyear welt. The single-layer vegetable-tanned leather sole keeps the profile low, and the CustomCork insole molds to your foot over time. It is a conservative, recraftable dress shoe that competes with the Park Avenue on the same 65 last, with brogue perforations giving it a slightly softer look.

Best forMen who need a conservative interview or office shoeShoppers who want a recraftable, long-life dress shoeWearers of suits and dark wool trousersAnyone replacing a worn-out pair of black cap-toe oxfords
Pros
  • Goodyear welted, so the sole can be replaced by Allen Edmonds rather than thrown away
  • Full-grain European calfskin with a polished finish and clean cap-toe line
  • CustomCork insole molds to the foot after a break-in period
  • Buyers report it runs true to size
  • Handcrafted in the US from imported leather
  • Works across seasons with suits, flannel and wool
Cons
  • Leather outsole is slick on wet pavement and wears faster than rubber
  • Stiff out of the box; needs several wears to break in
  • Brogue perforations make it slightly less formal than a plain cap toe
  • Leather sole and uppers need trees, rotation and occasional conditioning
  • Some buyers report the shoe presses on the top of the foot

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford prices at every store

  • DepopPre-owned

    In stock

    $150.00Checked 18 h ago
    Visit Depop
  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $199.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $249.00Checked 5 min ago
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $369.00Free shippingChecked 4 h ago
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • Sherman Brothers ShoesNew

    In stock

    $450.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Sherman Brothers Shoes
  • J. Men's ClothingNew

    In stock

    $450.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit J. Men's Clothing
  • WhatnotNew

    Availability unknown

    $99.99Checked Nov 21
    Visit Whatnot
  • Books of DiscoveryNew

    Availability unknown

    $119.00Checked Nov 13
    Visit Books of Discovery
  • Sui Generis Designer ConsignmentNew

    Availability unknown

    $202.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Sui Generis Designer Consignment
  • Sui Generis Designer ConsignmentPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $202.00Checked 10 h ago
    Visit Sui Generis Designer Consignment
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownSold by skyhawks0012

    $214.40Checked Nov 20
    Visit eBay
  • PoshmarkPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $228.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit Poshmark
  • PoshmarkNew

    Availability unknown

    $275.00Checked Nov 21
    Visit Poshmark
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $369.00Free shippingChecked Nov 19
    Visit Amazon
  • holidayhillapartamenty.plNew

    Availability unknownShips from Poland · duties may apply

    $400.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit holidayhillapartamenty.pl
  • O'Connell'sNew

    Availability unknown

    $425.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit O'Connell's
  • EditorialistNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Editorialist
  • Daphne's Shoe BoutiqueNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Daphne's Shoe Boutique
  • MensDesignerShoe.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked 10 h ago
    Visit MensDesignerShoe.com
  • BumpBuddiesNew

    Availability unknown

    $90.00Checked Nov 2
    Visit BumpBuddies
  • eBayPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $275.00Checked Oct 31
    Visit eBay
  • ilkbaharinsaat.com.trPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $395.00Checked Nov 3
    Visit ilkbaharinsaat.com.tr

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford price history

$270.00$49.99
Oct 30Nov 22

Lowest price we've seen: $49.99 on Nov 15 at Whatnot; highest $270.00 on Nov 11. Tracked across 17 stores since Oct 30.

What reviewers say

  • 4.4 / 52,800 ratings

Rated 4.4 out of 5 across about 2,800 ratings. Owners mostly praise the fit, the classic shape and the long-term durability of the welted construction, while some complain about a stiff break-in, the fragile leather sole and scattered quality issues.

What people mention
  • FitPraisedBuyers say it runs true to size and the last suits most feet.
  • Break-inMixedComfortable after a few wears, but stiff and tight at first.
  • Sole durabilityCriticisedThe single leather outsole is slippery when wet and wears faster than rubber.
  • Build qualityPraisedGoodyear welt and US handcrafting are cited as reasons the shoe lasts and can be resoled.
  • FinishMixedMost pairs arrive clean, but some owners report stitching or polish flaws.
  • Top-of-foot pressureCriticisedSome wearers say the shoe presses on the top of the foot.

From Allen Edmonds

  • Lace-up balmoral dress shoe with brogue detailing
  • 360° Goodyear welt construction for durability and stability
  • Soft leather lining
  • Single layer, vegetable-tanned leather outsoles for a sleek, low profile
  • CustomCork insoles mold to the unique shape of your foot
  • Handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin with imported materials
Sizes
5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10, 10.5, 11, 11.5, 12, 12.5, 13, 14, 15, 16
Materials
Ultra-refined, premium European calfskin leather upper; soft leather lining; vegetable-tanned leather outsoles
Fit
Classic, take your regular size
Sizing
Reviews say these are true to size; the page says classic fit, take your regular size.
Shipping
Receive in 3-5 business days with standard shipping; free store pickup.

About the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford

The Fifth Avenue is a men's lace-up balmoral oxford with a cap toe, almond-shaped toe and subtle brogue detailing. It is a dress shoe with a smooth, polished leather finish. The upper is made from European calfskin leather, with a leather lining and a CustomCork™ insole that molds to the shape of the foot. The shoe is built on the 65 last and has a single layer of vegetable-tanned leather sole for a low profile. Construction is a 360° Goodyear bench welt for durability and stability.

The shoe is handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin with imported materials and can be recrafted. It has a classic fit, so take your regular size, and it is available in normal and wide widths.

Type
Men's lace-up balmoral oxford
Toe
Almond cap toe
Detailing
Brogue detailing
Upper
European calfskin leather
Lining
Leather
Insole
CustomCork™
Outsole
Single layer vegetable-tanned leather
Construction
360° Goodyear bench welt
Last
65 last
Fit
Classic; take your regular size
Width
Normal and wide
Sizes
US 5 to 16
Colors
Red, Brown
Made in
Port Washington, Wisconsin, with imported materials

What buyers say

Buyers like
  • Comfortable to wear
  • Excellent quality and craftsmanship
  • Classic style that draws compliments
  • Well made and built to last
  • Great fit
  • Premium materials
Buyers complain about
  • Some quality issues reported
  • Hurts the top of the feet for some wearers

Specifications

Gender
Men's
Type
Oxford
Closure Style
Lace-up
Material
Leather
Leather Material
European calfskin leather, Vegetable-tanned leather
Occasion
Formal
Age Group
Adult
Department

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Questions and answers

Is the Fifth Avenue true to size?
Buyers and the brand's fit guidance say yes; most men order their usual US dress-shoe size. If you wear thick socks or have wide feet, consider the wider width.
How does it compare with the Park Avenue?
Both are cap-toe balmorals on similar lasts. The Fifth Avenue adds brogue detailing and a slightly softer look; the Park Avenue is plainer and more strictly formal.
How long does the leather sole last?
With regular wear and dry storage, expect a few years before a resole. The Goodyear welt means Allen Edmonds can replace the sole instead of you buying a new pair.
What's in the box?
One pair of shoes with laces; shoe trees and polish are sold separately.
Can the sole be replaced?
Yes. The 360° Goodyear welt allows recrafting by Allen Edmonds, which restores the sole and cork footbed.
Where is the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford cheapest?
At Whatnot, for $99.99, 45% off, as of our latest check.
Is the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford at its lowest price?
The lowest price we've seen is $49.99 at Whatnot on November 15, against $99.99 now.
What do buyers say about the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford?
Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 2,800 ratings. Buyers like: Comfortable to wear; Excellent quality and craftsmanship; Classic style that draws compliments. Common complaints: Some quality issues reported; Hurts the top of the feet for some wearers.
Where can I buy the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford?
15 stores we checked sell it, including Allen Edmonds, Sui Generis Designer Consignment, O'Connell's, Editorialist, Sherman Brothers Shoes.

Stores we've priced the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford at

  • Allen Edmonds deals and prices
  • Books of Discovery deals and prices
  • Whatnot deals and prices

More from Allen Edmonds

  • A
    Allen Edmonds Tompkins Men's Boot
    Allen Edmonds Tompkins Men's Boot
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
    Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
Recraftable
Yes, by Allen Edmonds
Occasion
Formal, dress
Men's
Outsole Material
Leather
Season
Winter, Fall, Spring, Summer
Sole Material
Vegetable-tanned leather
Sole Support
Stability
Sole Style
Single layer
Color Effect
Polished finish
Toe Shape
Almond Toe
Toe Style
Cap toe
Insole Material
CustomCork™
Lining Material
Leather
Lining Type
Lined interior
Pattern
Brogue detailing
Texture
Smooth, Polished finish
Design Style
Formal
Decorative Accents
Brogue detailing
Gore-Tex
Noklarna.com
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Plain Toe Derby
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Plain Toe Derby
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Men's Shoe
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Men's Shoe
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Park Cap Toe Boot
    Allen Edmonds Park Cap Toe Boot
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Derby Leather
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Derby Leather
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Winston Wingtip Brogue Derby
    Allen Edmonds Winston Wingtip Brogue Derby
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Randolph Penny Loafer
    Allen Edmonds Randolph Penny Loafer
  • All Allen Edmonds deals and products →

    More men's oxfords

    • D
      Dockers Fairborne Men's Oxford
      Dockers Fairborne Men's Oxford
    • R
      Rockport Floran Men's Oxford
      Rockport Floran Men's Oxford
    • F
      Florsheim Francisco ct OX
      Florsheim Francisco ct OX
    • V
      Vance Co Men's Nikola Slip-on Oxford Shoes
      Vance Co Men's Nikola Slip-on Oxford Shoes
    • L
      LibertyZeno Formal Leather Oxford Dress Shoes
      LibertyZeno Formal Leather Oxford Dress Shoes
    • L
      Lozano Lopez Italian Genuine Leather Shoes, Emerald Green, Size 12
      Lozano Lopez Italian Genuine Leather Shoes, Emerald Green, Size 12
    • G
      Girotti Men's Green Premium Leather Plain-Toe Oxford Dress Shoes
      Girotti Men's Green Premium Leather Plain-Toe Oxford Dress Shoes
    • G
      Girotti Men's Forest Green Suede Oxford Shoes
      Girotti Men's Forest Green Suede Oxford Shoes