Is $43.65 a good price for the Badgley Mischka Effie?

Yes. That is far below typical Badgley Mischka evening shoe pricing, and it is the best of the 4 new listings as of November 6, 2026. Check the seller's return policy before buying at that price.

How does the Effie fit?

Reports are mixed. Some buyers take their usual size, others go up a half size, especially in the pointed toe. Order from a store with free returns if you can.

Can I wear the Effie all day?

It is an occasion shoe. It works for a ceremony, photos and a seated dinner, but the slim heel and pointed toe are not made for long walks or standing shifts.

What is the upper made of?

Depending on the colorway, the upper is velvet, shimmer fabric or silk satin, with a leather outsole. None of the versions are waterproof.

What sizes does it come in?

Listings run from women's 5 to 11, including half sizes at the low end. Availability varies by fabric and color.

When is the Effie cheapest?

Prices on past-season evening shoes tend to drop after wedding season and around major sales events. Watch the price history for the size and color you want.

Where is the Badgley Mischka Effie cheapest?

At eBay, for $43.65, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Badgley Mischka Effie?

Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 8 ratings.

Where can I buy the Badgley Mischka Effie?

8 stores we checked sell it, including eBay, Walmart, Zulily.com, Bluefly, Badgley Mischka Web.

Browse

Badgley Mischka Effie

Best price now

$43.65at eBayObserved at 12:03 PM

Compared across 4 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit eBay

Badgley Mischka Effie

Best price now

$43.65at eBayObserved at 12:03 PM

Compared across 4 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit eBay

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Our take on the Badgley Mischka Effie

The Badgley Mischka Effie is a women's dress pump with a pointed toe and a slim heel, built in velvet, shimmer fabric or silk satin uppers over a leather outsole. It is a formal, occasion shoe meant for weddings, galas and evening wear rather than daily walking. The best new price is $43.65 at eBay as of November 6, 2026, well below what Badgley Mischka evening shoes typically cost at full retail, with 4 stores listing it new.

Best forWedding guests and bridal partiesBlack-tie and cocktail eventsShoppers who want a designer evening shoe at a discountNarrow, dressy outfits that need a pointed pump

Pros

Pointed-toe pump silhouette that reads formal
Velvet, satin and shimmer uppers suit evening wear
Leather outsole is a step up from synthetic soles
Available in a wide run of sizes from 5 to 11
Deep discount at $43.65 versus typical designer pricing

Cons

Slim heel and pointed toe are not built for long standing or walking
Velvet and satin uppers scuff and stain easily
Not waterproof, so wet weather and outdoor venues are risky
Sizing runs inconsistently across the fabric options

Badgley Mischka Effie prices at every store

eBayNew
In stock
$43.65Observed at 12:03 PM
Visit store
WalmartNew
Availability unknownSold by La Via
$47.99Observed at 12:03 PM
Visit store
Zulily.comNew
Availability unknown
$48.99Observed at 12:03 PM
Visit store
BlueflyNew
Availability unknown
$48.99Observed at 12:03 PM
Visit store

Also available at

Badgley Mischka WebCheck price at Badgley Mischka Web
LystCheck price at Lyst
Nordstrom RackCheck price at Nordstrom Rack
PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark

Badgley Mischka Effie price history

Lowest price we've seen: $43.65 on Nov 6 at eBay. Tracked across 8 stores since Nov 6.

What reviewers say

Owners of Badgley Mischka evening shoes generally praise the dressy look and the comfort relative to other heels, while complaining about sizing and how delicate the fabric uppers are.

What people mention

FitMixedBuyers report the Effie runs small for some and true to size for others, so trying a half size up is common.
ComfortMixedOwners find it wearable for a ceremony and photos but not for hours of standing.
Fabric careCriticisedSatin and velvet uppers pick up scuffs and stains that are hard to clean.
StylePraisedThe pointed toe and slim heel are called elegant and event-ready.
Heel stabilityCriticisedThe thin heel sinks into grass and wobbles on uneven pavement.

Specifications

Numeric Size: 6.5
Fit Width: No information
Department: Women's
Suitable For Size: Women's Size
Age Group: Adult
Material: Velvet, Leather, Shimmer Fabric, Silk Satin
Upper Material: Velvet, Shimmer Fabric, Silk Satin

Questions and answers

Is $43.65 a good price for the Badgley Mischka Effie?: Yes. That is far below typical Badgley Mischka evening shoe pricing, and it is the best of the 4 new listings as of November 6, 2026. Check the seller's return policy before buying at that price.
How does the Effie fit?: Reports are mixed. Some buyers take their usual size, others go up a half size, especially in the pointed toe. Order from a store with free returns if you can.
Can I wear the Effie all day?: It is an occasion shoe. It works for a ceremony, photos and a seated dinner, but the slim heel and pointed toe are not made for long walks or standing shifts.
What is the upper made of?: Depending on the colorway, the upper is velvet, shimmer fabric or silk satin, with a leather outsole. None of the versions are waterproof.
What sizes does it come in?: Listings run from women's 5 to 11, including half sizes at the low end. Availability varies by fabric and color.
When is the Effie cheapest?: Prices on past-season evening shoes tend to drop after wedding season and around major sales events. Watch the price history for the size and color you want.
Where is the Badgley Mischka Effie cheapest?: At eBay, for $43.65, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Badgley Mischka Effie?: Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 8 ratings.
Where can I buy the Badgley Mischka Effie?: 8 stores we checked sell it, including eBay, Walmart, Zulily.com, Bluefly, Badgley Mischka Web.