Are the Baffin Bobcaygeon boots actually waterproof?

Yes. The upper is built to keep water out, and owners report dry feet in slush and wet snow. Water can still enter over the top of the shaft in deep drifts.

How warm are they, and can I wear them indoors?

They are made for freezing and sub-freezing weather and hold heat well. Most owners find them too warm for long stretches indoors or on mild days.

Do they run true to size?

They fit close to standard US sizing with room for thick socks. If you wear very heavy socks or have wide feet, consider going up half a size.

How do they compare with lighter winter boots?

They are warmer and grippier than fashion snow boots but heavier and bulkier. If you mostly walk cleared city streets, a lighter boot may suit you better.

What are the Bobcaygeon boots best for?

Commuting, shovelling and standing outdoors in cold, snowy weather. They are less suited to mild days or dressier outfits.

How should I care for them?

Brush off salt and snow after each wear and let them air-dry away from direct heat. A waterproofing treatment on the upper helps keep them shedding water.