StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Caitlyn Minimalist
Caitlyn Minimalist
Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658

Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658

4.6(182 ratings)

Best price now

$20.30at EtsyChecked Nov 9

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Etsy

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Price facts

  • Last seen at $20.30 at Etsy on Nov 9.

Our take on the Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658

These are square-cut cubic zirconia stud earrings from Caitlyn Minimalist, offered in 12 birthstone colors with a flat-back screw-back closure. The geometric, deco-style setting and the choice of stone color make them a personal gift or a subtle everyday stud. Buyers like the understated look and say the flat backs are comfortable enough to sleep in, even for sensitive ears. The main complaints are practical: the screw-on fronts are fiddly, the posts run thick and long for some piercings, and the gold plating has worn off quickly for at least one owner.

Best forEveryday wear in lobe, cartilage or tragus piercingsA birthstone gift for a birthday or new babyShoppers with sensitive ears who want flat-back studsMinimal, geometric jewelry fans
Pros
  • Square-cut stone gives a clean, deco-inspired look
  • 12 birthstone colors to choose from
  • Flat-back screw-backs sit flush and suit side sleepers
  • Reported as comfortable for sensitive ears
  • Comes in a reusable jewelry box, with gift wrapping available
Cons
  • Screw-on fronts are fiddly to put in
  • Posts are thick and long for some piercings and lobes
  • Gold plating reported to wear off within about a week
  • Stone colors can look duller than the photos
  • Size and heft differ from some buyers' expectations

Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658 prices at every store

  • EtsyNew

    In stockSold by CaitlynMinimalist

    $20.30Checked Nov 9
    Visit Etsy

Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658 price history

Lowest price we've seen: $20.30 on Nov 10 at Etsy. Tracked across 1 store since Nov 10.

What reviewers say

  • 4.6 / 5182 ratings

With 182 ratings averaging 4.6, buyers mostly call these earrings understated, good quality and as described, and many find them comfortable enough to sleep in. Complaints center on the screw-back closure, post sizing and plating wear.

What people mention
  • ClosureCriticisedBuyers find the screw-on fronts fiddly and slow to put in.
  • FitMixedSome say the posts are too thick or too long for their lobes and piercings, while others wear them comfortably.
  • PlatingCriticisedAt least one owner reports the gold plating wore off after about a week.
  • Stone colorMixedSeveral buyers say the stones look duller or more muted than in the photos.
  • ComfortPraisedOwners call the flat backs comfortable enough to sleep in and gentle on sensitive ears.
  • LookPraisedBuyers describe the square setting as understated and true to the listing.

From Etsy

  • Square-cut cubic zirconia birthstone stud earrings with a geometric, deco-inspired look
  • Choose your birthstone color from 12 options
  • Flat-back screw-back design for comfortable all-day wear
  • Can be worn in earlobe, cartilage and tragus piercings
  • Personalizable with your choice of birthstone
  • Gift wrapping with ribbon available at checkout
Materials
925 Sterling Silver; 18K Gold or Silver color; ~3.5mm square cubic zirconia gemstone
Fit
Flat-back stud earrings; gauge 19; sold as a pair
Care
Avoid prolonged exposure to salt water, chlorine, perfumes, lotions and other harsh chemicals; gold-plated pieces have an anti-tarnish coating and are water res
Guarantee
Ready to Ship items are covered by a 1 year quality guarantee; custom pieces are final sale
Returns
Returns accepted for Ready to Ship items within 14 days from delivery for store credit or exchange; items must be in mint condition and original packaging; buye
Shipping
Free shipping; ships from Irvine, CA; ready to ship in 1-2 business days; estimated delivery Nov 16-24
In the box
One pair of square birthstone stud earrings, Elegant, reusable and recyclable jewelry box

About the Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658

These stud earrings feature a square-cut cubic zirconia birthstone with a geometric, deco-inspired look. The gemstone measures about 3.5 mm and comes in 12 birthstone color options, so the pair can be personalized.

The posts are made of 925 sterling silver and come in an 18K gold or silver color. The flat-back, screw-back design is made for comfortable all-day wear. The earrings can be worn in earlobe, cartilage and tragus piercings.

Avoid prolonged exposure to salt water, chlorine, perfumes, lotions and other harsh chemicals. Gold-plated pieces have an anti-tarnish coating and are water resistant.

Material
925 sterling silver
Finish
18K gold or silver color
Gemstone
Square cubic zirconia, about 3.5 mm
Colors
12 birthstone options
Closure
Flat-back, screw-back
Gauge
19
Wear
Earlobe, cartilage and tragus piercings
Sold as
One pair
In the box
One pair of earrings and a reusable, recyclable jewelry box

What buyers say

Buyers like
  • Looks great and understated
  • Great quality
  • As described
  • Fast shipping
  • Helpful seller
  • Comfortable enough to sleep in; good for sensitive ears
Buyers complain about
  • Hard to put in; screw-on front is fiddly
  • Posts too thick for some piercings
  • Gold plating wore off after about a week
  • Gemstone colors duller or more muted than pictured
  • Posts too long for some lobes
  • Some found them chunkier or smaller/cheaper-looking than expected

Questions and answers

Can I wear these in cartilage or tragus piercings?
Yes. The flat-back screw-back design is meant for lobe, cartilage and tragus piercings. Check the post gauge against your piercing, since some buyers found the posts thick.
Are the earrings good for sensitive ears?
Buyers with sensitive ears report no irritation, and the flat backs help. The plating is the weak point: one owner saw it wear off quickly, so keep them away from water and perfume.
How do the screw-backs work?
The front screws onto a threaded post rather than pushing on. It holds securely, but several buyers found it fiddly to line up and fasten.
Do the stones match the birthstone colors shown?
Some buyers say the stones are duller or more muted than the photos suggest. The square cut and lighting affect how vivid the color looks.
What comes in the box?
One pair of square birthstone stud earrings in a reusable, recyclable jewelry box. Gift wrapping with ribbon is offered at checkout.
Are they a good gift?
The birthstone choice and gift box make them an easy personalized gift. If the recipient has thick lobes or small piercings, check the post size first.
Where is the Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658 cheapest?
At Etsy, for $20.30, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658?
Rated 4.6 out of 5 from 182 ratings. Buyers like: Looks great and understated; Great quality; As described. Common complaints: Hard to put in; screw-on front is fiddly; Posts too thick for some piercings.

Stores we've priced the Caitlyn Minimalist Square Birthstone Stud Earrings ER658 at

  • Etsy deals and prices

More from Caitlyn Minimalist

  • C
    Caitlyn Minimalist Textured Stacking Ring Set
    Caitlyn Minimalist Textured Stacking Ring Set
  • C
    Caitlyn Minimalist Mama Necklaces
    Caitlyn Minimalist Mama Necklaces
  • C
    Caitlyn Minimalist Pave Heart Timepiece
    Caitlyn Minimalist Pave Heart Timepiece
All Caitlyn Minimalist deals and products →