Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie
Best price now
38% under what the other stores charge
Compared across 6 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when. Store links may earn us a commission.
Ask our agent about this product
It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.
Price facts
- Last seen at $22.50 at eBay on Nov 9.
- Checked at 6 stores.
Our take on the Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie
The Hartlie is a women's slip-on shoe from Circus NY, Sam Edelman's lower-priced line. It pairs a cushioned footbed with a supportive upper and a durable outsole, aimed at all-day wear. Shoppers rate it 3.7 out of 5, so reception is decent but not glowing. It competes with other budget slip-ons and loafers on comfort and looks rather than on premium materials.
- Cushioned footbed softens each step
- Supportive upper holds the foot
- Durable outsole with reliable traction
- Versatile enough for work or weekends
- Slip-on style is quick to put on
- Mixed ratings suggest fit varies between buyers
- Not a premium leather build at this tier
- Limited color and size availability reported by some
Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie prices at every store
- ShopSimonNew
In stock
$36.00Checked 16 h ago - ModeSensNew
In stock
$36.00Checked 16 h ago - KixRxNew
In stock
$36.00Checked 16 h ago - PoshmarkNew
In stock
$39.00Checked 16 h ago - WalmartNew
In stockSold by Apex Trading NY
$49.99Checked 16 h ago - eBayPre-owned
Availability unknownReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.
$18.00+ $8.00 shippingChecked Nov 9 - eBayNew
Availability unknownReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.
$22.50+ $6.71 shippingChecked Nov 9
Also available at
Store links may earn us a commission.
Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie price history
Lowest price we've seen: $36.00 on Nov 9 at ModeSens. Tracked across 6 stores since Nov 9.
What reviewers say
- 3.7 / 536 ratings
Ratings average 3.7 out of 5 across 36 reviews, so most buyers are satisfied but a notable share are not. Praise centers on comfort and versatility; complaints tend to be about fit and materials.
- ComfortPraisedBuyers say the cushioned footbed keeps feet comfortable through a full day.
- FitMixedSome buyers find the fit true to size, while others say it runs narrow or loose.
- VersatilityPraisedOwners wear it to work and on casual outings without changing shoes.
- MaterialsCriticisedSome reviewers feel the upper and outsole look and feel cheaper than expected.
- SupportMixedA few buyers find the support adequate; others want more structure for long standing.
From ShopSimon
- Cushioned footbed for soft underfoot support
- Supportive upper
- Helps minimize fatigue
- Durable outsole for reliable traction
- Versatile for casual outings, work, or semi-dressy occasions
- Blends chic design with all-day comfort
- Sizes
- US 8.5
- Shipping
- Usually ships within 1-2 business days
About the Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie
The Hartlie is a women's shoe from Circus NY by Sam Edelman. It has a cushioned footbed that gives soft underfoot support and a supportive upper. The design is meant to help minimize fatigue.
The outsole is durable and provides reliable traction. The shoe suits casual outings, work, or semi-dressy occasions.
- Brand
- Circus NY by Sam Edelman
- Style
- Hartlie
- Gender
- Women's
- Size
- US 8.5
- Footbed
- Cushioned
- Upper
- Supportive
- Outsole
- Durable, with reliable traction
- Occasions
- Casual outings, work, semi-dressy
Questions and answers
- Is the Hartlie true to size?
- Reviews are split. Many buyers take their usual size, but some report it running narrow or slightly loose, so trying both sizes is wise.
- Can you wear it to work?
- Yes. It is designed for casual, work and semi-dressy occasions, and owners wear it with office outfits.
- Is it good for standing all day?
- The cushioned footbed helps, but support is moderate. Buyers who need firm arch support may find it lacking.
- How does it compare with Sam Edelman's main line?
- Circus NY is the brand's more affordable line. Expect similar styling with simpler materials and less padding than the flagship Sam Edelman shoes.
- What is the sole like?
- It has a durable outsole with reliable traction, suited to everyday indoor and outdoor wear.
- Is it a slip-on?
- Yes, the Hartlie is a slip-on style, so it goes on quickly without laces or straps.
- Where is the Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie cheapest?
- At eBay, for $22.50, 38% under what the other stores charge, as of our latest check.
- What do buyers say about the Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie?
- Rated 3.7 out of 5 from 36 ratings.
- Where can I buy the Circus NY by Sam Edelman Women's Hartlie?
- 6 stores we checked sell it, including ShopSimon, ModeSens, Walmart, KixRx, Poshmark.
