Is the Club Room Tarhy worth buying?

At $34.99 at Macy's as of November 5, 2026, it is a cheap way to get a lace-up shoe that works for both office and casual wear. If you need a genuine leather dress shoe, spend more.

Does the Tarhy run true to size?

It is listed in medium width only, so buyers with wide feet should size up or look elsewhere. Most reviewers rate the fit well, but some find it narrow.

Can I wear these as formal dress shoes?

They are styled as casual dress shoes with a rubber outsole. They suit business casual, weddings and dinners, but not strict formal dress codes.

What colors does the Tarhy come in?

Cognac and Black Beauty. Both use the same round toe and lace-up design.

When is the best time to buy the Tarhy?

The current $34.99 at Macy's as of November 5, 2026 is already near the bottom of its price range. Clearance and holiday sales are the times to watch for further drops.

Where is the Club Room Tarhy Casual Dress Shoes cheapest?

At Macy's, for $34.99, 50% off, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Club Room Tarhy Casual Dress Shoes?

Rated 4 out of 5 from 36 ratings. Buyers like: Comfortable for wearing throughout the day; Versatile style suitable for various occasions; Look good. Common complaints: Some expected leather but uppers are manmade; Feels too wide for some.