Does it have a bagel setting?

No. It has a defrost function only, so bagels toast on the same cycle as bread.

Can it fit thick bagels?

Yes. The slots are wide and the high-lift lever helps lift thicker or smaller pieces out.

Slide out the removable crumb tray and empty it. Wipe the stainless exterior with a damp cloth.

Is it worth it over a toaster with more settings?

If you only toast bread and frozen slices, it covers the basics. If you want bagel, reheat and cancel controls, a rival with those modes suits you better.

Where is the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster cheapest?

At Target, for $25.99, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster?

Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 80 ratings.

Where can I buy the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster?

5 stores we checked sell it, including Hamilton Beach, Rebel, Target, Shipt, DoorDash.

Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster

Best price now

$25.99at TargetChecked 21 h ago

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Target

Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster

Best price now

$25.99at TargetChecked 21 h ago

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Target

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $25.99 at Target on Nov 9.
Checked at 5 stores.

Our take on the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster

The Hamilton Beach Sure Toast is a two-slice stainless steel toaster with wide slots, a defrost setting, high-lift levers and a removable crumb tray. It is a basic, budget-minded toaster aimed at everyday bread and bagel duty. It lacks the browning dial precision and extra modes (bagel, reheat, cancel) that many rivals at this level include. Owner ratings sit around average, with uneven browning the most common complaint.

Best forBudget shoppers wanting a simple two-slice toasterHouseholds toasting standard sandwich breadBagel and frozen-bread users who want wide slots and defrostBuyers who prefer stainless steel looks

Pros

Wide slots fit bagels and thicker slices
Defrost setting handles frozen bread
High-lift lever makes small slices easier to remove
Removable crumb tray simplifies cleaning
Stainless steel body looks tidy on the counter

Cons

Browning is uneven across the two slots
No bagel, reheat or cancel buttons
Browning dial offers coarse control
Some owners report inconsistent results from slice to slice

Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster prices at every store

RebelPre-owned
In stock
$15.99Checked 21 h ago
Visit Rebel
TargetNew
In stock
$25.99Checked 21 h ago
Visit Target
Hamilton BeachNew
In stock
$32.99Checked 21 h ago
Visit Hamilton Beach
ShiptNew
Out of stock
$32.99Checked 21 h ago
Visit Shipt
DoorDashNew
Out of stockSold by Target US
$41.29Checked 21 h ago
Visit DoorDash

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster price history

Lowest price we've seen: $25.99 on Nov 10 at Target. Tracked across 4 stores since Nov 10.

What reviewers say

3.5 / 580 ratings

Owners rate it around average. Many like the wide slots and easy cleanup, but uneven toasting and limited settings come up often.

What people mention

Browning evennessCriticisedOwners say one slot often browns darker than the other on the same setting.
Slot widthPraisedWide slots are cited as a plus for bagels and thicker slices.
ControlsCriticisedReviewers miss bagel, reheat and cancel options found on rival toasters.
CleaningPraisedThe removable crumb tray is described as easy to pull out and empty.
BuildMixedThe stainless finish is liked, but some find the body light and plasticky in places.

Specifications

Size: 2-slice
Stainless Steel: Yes
Crumb Tray: Yes
With Wide Slot: Yes
Wattage: 850 W
Color: Stainless SteelSource
Number of Toast Slices (pcs)

Questions and answers

Does it have a bagel setting?: No. It has a defrost function only, so bagels toast on the same cycle as bread.
Can it fit thick bagels?: Yes. The slots are wide and the high-lift lever helps lift thicker or smaller pieces out.
How do I clean it?: Slide out the removable crumb tray and empty it. Wipe the stainless exterior with a damp cloth.
Is it worth it over a toaster with more settings?: If you only toast bread and frozen slices, it covers the basics. If you want bagel, reheat and cancel controls, a rival with those modes suits you better.
How many slices does it toast?: Two at a time, at 850 watts.
Where is the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster cheapest?: At Target, for $25.99, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster?: Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 80 ratings.
Where can I buy the Hamilton Beach Sure Toast Toaster?: 5 stores we checked sell it, including Hamilton Beach, Rebel, Target, Shipt, DoorDash.