Does the Beck Penny work with orthotics?

Yes. The insole is removable, so you can swap in your own orthotic. The leather lining and cushioned footbed still give some support underneath.

How does it fit compared with other Johnston & Murphy loafers?

It runs true to size for most wearers, though some find it slightly narrow. If you are between sizes or have a wide foot, consider going up half a size.

Is it dressy enough for a suit?

It works with a sport coat and chinos, but the rubber outsole makes it less formal than a leather-soled dress shoe. For a suit, a leather-soled loafer is the safer pick.

How should I care for the leather?

Use a leather conditioner and a horsehair brush, and keep cedar shoe trees in them between wears. Avoid soaking them; wipe off water and let them dry away from direct heat.

Is it a slip-on or does it lace?

It is a slip-on penny loafer with a decorative strap. The laced option refers to the strap detail, not a functional lace-up closure.

Where is the Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny cheapest?

At Dillard's, for $59.99, as of our latest check.

Where can I buy the Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny?

6 stores we checked sell it, including Zappos, Dillard's, Nordstrom Rack, Lyst, ModeSens.

Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny

Best price now

$59.99at Dillard'sChecked 12 h ago

Compared across 6 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Dillard's

Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny

Best price now

$59.99at Dillard'sChecked 12 h ago

Compared across 6 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Dillard's

Johnston & Murphy discount code →

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $59.99 at Dillard's on Nov 10.
Checked at 6 stores.

Our take on the Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny

The Beck Penny is Johnston & Murphy's take on the classic penny loafer, built on a leather upper with a leather and microfiber lining and a rubber outsole. It weighs about 10.3 oz and has a removable insole, so it takes orthotics. The slip-on penny strap and leather lining put it in dress-casual territory, above rubber-soled casual loafers and below the brand's handcrafted benchmade line. It suits men who want a loafer that works with chinos or a sport coat and can handle a long day on their feet.

Best forMen who want a dress-casual penny loaferTravel and long days on your feetWearers who need a removable insole for orthoticsOffice and smart-casual wardrobes

Pros

Classic penny loafer shape that works dressed up or down
Leather lining and microfiber lining for comfort
Removable insole accepts custom orthotics
Rubber outsole adds grip over leather soles
Light at about 10.3 oz per shoe
Slip-on entry with a laced option

Cons

Rubber outsole looks less refined than a leather sole
Leather upper needs breaking in
Limited to black in this listing
Not a true dress shoe for formal wear

Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny prices at every store

Dillard'sNew
In stock
$59.99Checked 12 h ago
Visit Dillard's
Nordstrom RackNew
In stock
$69.97Checked 12 h ago
Visit Nordstrom Rack
ZapposNew
In stock
$83.93Free shippingChecked 12 h ago
Visit Zappos
LystNew
Availability unknown
$69.97Checked 12 h ago
Visit Lyst
ModeSensNew
Availability unknown
$70.00Checked 12 h ago
Visit ModeSens
eBayNew
Availability unknownSold by modahut
$133.99Checked 12 h ago
Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny price history

Lowest price we've seen: $59.99 on Nov 10 at Dillard's. Tracked across 6 stores since Nov 10.

What reviewers say

Owners of Johnston & Murphy loafers generally rate the Beck line as comfortable out of the box and well made for the price tier, with the leather lining and cushioned insole getting the most praise. Some note the leather takes a few wears to soften and that the rubber sole is less dressy than a leather one.

What people mention

ComfortPraisedOwners say the cushioned insole and leather lining make these comfortable for long days.
Break-inMixedSome say the leather is stiff at first and softens after a few wears.
OutsoleMixedThe rubber outsole is praised for grip but seen as less dressy than leather.
FitMixedA few wearers find the fit slightly narrow and suggest sizing carefully.
BuildPraisedReviewers describe the construction as solid for the price tier.

Specifications

Gender Size: Men's 10.5, Men's 11.5
Men'S Size: Size 10.5
Age Group Size: Adult size
Occasion: Travel, Long days on your feet
Department: Men's
Suitable For Size: Adult size, Men's Size
Age Group: Adult

Questions and answers

Does the Beck Penny work with orthotics?: Yes. The insole is removable, so you can swap in your own orthotic. The leather lining and cushioned footbed still give some support underneath.
How does it fit compared with other Johnston & Murphy loafers?: It runs true to size for most wearers, though some find it slightly narrow. If you are between sizes or have a wide foot, consider going up half a size.
Is it dressy enough for a suit?: It works with a sport coat and chinos, but the rubber outsole makes it less formal than a leather-soled dress shoe. For a suit, a leather-soled loafer is the safer pick.
What is the upper made of?: The upper is leather, with a leather and microfiber lining and a rubber outsole. It weighs about 10.3 oz per shoe.
How should I care for the leather?: Use a leather conditioner and a horsehair brush, and keep cedar shoe trees in them between wears. Avoid soaking them; wipe off water and let them dry away from direct heat.
Is it a slip-on or does it lace?: It is a slip-on penny loafer with a decorative strap. The laced option refers to the strap detail, not a functional lace-up closure.
Where is the Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny cheapest?: At Dillard's, for $59.99, as of our latest check.
Where can I buy the Johnston & Murphy Beck Penny?: 6 stores we checked sell it, including Zappos, Dillard's, Nordstrom Rack, Lyst, ModeSens.