Is the Johnston & Murphy Upton worth it at $78.97?

At $78.97 at eBay as of November 8, 2026, it is well below typical J&M dress-shoe prices. If you want a leather oxford for work or events and the size fits, it is a solid buy.

How does the Upton fit compared with other Johnston & Murphy shoes?

Owners say it runs narrow, so wide-footed buyers should consider sizing up or ordering a wide width. Try it on with the socks you plan to wear.

Is the Upton a true dress shoe or business casual?

It is a plain-toe oxford with perforated detail, so it works for suits and for business casual. It is dressier than a loafer but less formal than a cap-toe.

What is the upper made of?

The upper is leather, cut as a single piece with perforated detailing. The one-piece build means fewer seams than a standard stitched oxford.

When is the Upton cheapest?

Dress shoes like this tend to drop during seasonal sales and clearance events. The current $78.97 at eBay is already far below list, so waiting may not beat it.