DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai
Macy's
Macy's Birthstone Stud Earrings in 14k Gold or 14k White Gold

Macy's Birthstone Stud Earrings in 14k Gold or 14k White Gold

3.5· 187 ratings

Last price we saw

$149.00last seen Oct 28

Prices change often: ask the agent below to check today's price at every store.

Deal: 77% off at Macy's →

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Our take on the Macy's Birthstone Stud Earrings in 14k Gold or 14k White Gold

These are Macy's birthstone stud earrings in 14k yellow or white gold, with round gemstones about 1/5 inch across. The lineup covers most birthstones, from garnet and amethyst to pink sapphire, and includes lab-grown options such as emerald and white sapphire. The white gold version is rhodium plated for extra shine. Pricing moves with the stone and metal you pick, so compare the specific birthstone you want against its own recent range rather than the listing as a whole.

Best forA birthstone gift for a birthday or new babyEveryday small studs for a second or third piercingShoppers who want real 14k gold without a high priceBuying lab-grown stones for a lower cost
Pros
  • Solid 14k gold posts and settings
  • Wide birthstone selection, including lab-grown options
  • About 1/5 inch wide, a true small stud
  • White gold is rhodium plated for shine
  • Free in-store cleaning at participating Macy's
Cons
  • Stones run smaller than many buyers expect
  • Gem color can differ from the online photos
  • Some owners report loose backs and bent posts
  • Treated stones need careful cleaning and storage
  • Quality complaints at this price point

Macy's Birthstone Stud Earrings in 14k Gold or 14k White Gold price history

Lowest price we've seen: $149.00 on Oct 28. Tracked across 1 store since Oct 28.

What reviewers say

Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 187 ratings. Buyers like the sparkle and clarity of the stones and wear them daily, but size and color disappointments are common, and several owners had backs fall off or posts fail.

Pros
  • Bright, clear stones with good sparkle
  • Comfortable for everyday wear
  • Good value for 14k gold
  • Popular as gifts
Cons
  • Smaller in person than pictured
  • Stone color differs from the website images
  • Earring backs get lost or loosen
  • Posts and backs feel flimsy for the price

From Macy's

  • Round-shape birthstone stud earrings set in 14k gold or 14k white gold
  • Available in a range of birthstones including Garnet, Amethyst, Aquamarine, Blue Topaz, Citrine, Peridot, Pink Sapphire and more
  • Lab-grown gemstone options chemically, physically and optically identical to natural gems
  • Approx. diameter: 1/5"
  • White gold has a rhodium plating to improve shine and luster
  • Free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating Macy's
Materials
14k gold or 14k white gold; gemstones vary by birthstone (e.g., Blue Topaz 1 ct. t.w., Garnet 1 ct. t.w., Cultured Freshwater Pearl 5mm)
Sizing
Customers on average rate the runs small/runs large as Neutral; reviewers frequently mention the earrings are smaller than anticipated
Care
Almost all gemstones have been treated to enhance their beauty and require special care; rhodium plating on white gold will wear off and can be reapplied by a j
Returns
Returns accepted within 30 days of purchase with tags attached; Last Act items are final sale
Shipping
This item may not be shipped to P.O. Box, Puerto Rico, Guam, Alaska, Hawaii, U.S. Virgin Islands, Armed Forces addresses and other listed locations; fine jewelr

What buyers say

Buyers like
  • Beautiful stones with bright luster and stunning clarity
  • Suitable for everyday wear
  • Great deal and cherished purchase
  • Sparkling, pretty earrings
Buyers complain about
  • Earrings are smaller than anticipated
  • Color accuracy of gemstones differs from online images
  • Earring backs or posts have durability issues
  • Back support keeps getting lost
  • Poorly made for the money

Specifications

Material
Gold, White Gold
Metal Type
Gold
Gold Karatage
14k
Metal Color
White Gold
Jewelry Type
Stud, Earrings
Style
Classic, Casual
Gemstone Carat Weight
9/10 ct. t.w. (Lab-Grown Emerald)

Questions and answers

Are these earrings worth it?
If you want real 14k gold studs with a birthstone at a modest price, yes. Expect a small stone and check the color in person or in store photos, since online images can mislead.
How big are they?
The stud is about 1/5 inch in diameter, so it sits close to the lobe. Many buyers say they look smaller in person than on screen.
Is the emerald real?
The emerald option is lab-grown, which means it has the same chemical and optical properties as a mined emerald. Most other stones are treated to enhance color and clarity.
Can I wear them every day?
Yes, 14k gold suits daily wear. Take them off before swimming or showering and clean treated stones gently, since they need special care.
What comes in the box?
You get the pair of studs with their backs. Macy's lists free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating stores, but no travel case is mentioned.
When is the best time to buy?
Birthstone jewelry tends to drop around Mother's Day, the holidays and Macy's storewide jewelry sales. Watch the price history for your specific stone and metal.
What do buyers say about the Macy's Birthstone Stud Earrings in 14k Gold or 14k White Gold?
Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 187 ratings. Buyers like: Beautiful stones with bright luster and stunning clarity; Suitable for everyday wear; Great deal and cherished purchase. Common complaints: Earrings are smaller than anticipated; Color accuracy of gemstones differs from online images.
Gemstone Type
Birthstone, Opal, Peridot, Ruby, Sapphire
Gemstone Cut
Round-shape
Gemstone Shape
Round
Gemstone Treatment
Lab-Grown (Emerald), Treated to enhance beauty (almost all gemstones)
Theme
Jewel
Shape
Round
Target Audience
Adult, Female
Embellishment
Gem Embellishment
Silhouette
Circle
Size
os
Width
No information
Weight
3/8 ct. tw (lab-grown white sapphire)
Care Instructions
Require special care (almost all gemstones)