Is $140 a good price for these earrings?

It is the only price recorded since October 29, 2026, at $140 at Macy's, so there is no cheaper point in the tracked history. For 1/4 carat of diamond in sterling silver, that is a typical department-store price rather than an exceptional deal.

Do these look like real diamond studs?

From a few feet away, yes. The cluster of round-cut stones spreads light across a 1/2 inch face, so they read larger than 1/4 carat. Up close, the I3 clarity and I-J color are visible.

How big are they actually?

About 1/2 inch in diameter and roughly 1/4 inch wide, which is a medium stud. Several buyers said they looked smaller in person than in photos, so check the measurement against a pair you already own.

Are the diamonds treated?

Yes. The listing states the stones are treated to enhance their beauty, which is common at this clarity grade. Keep them away from harsh chemicals and have them checked if a stone loosens.

The earrings come as a pair with standard push backs. Macy's lists free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating stores, but that is a service, not an included item.

Will sterling silver bother sensitive ears?

Sterling silver is 92.5% silver, and the posts are silver too, so it suits most people who react to base metal. If you have reacted to silver before, check the backing material before buying.

What do buyers say about the Macy's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver?

Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 57 ratings. Buyers like: Described as beautiful, lovely, and brilliant; Noted for shine and sparkle; Size found just right for various occasions. Common complaints: Some say the earrings appear smaller than expected.

Macy's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver: 65% off at Macy's

What reviewers say

With 4.4 out of 5 from 57 ratings, owners mostly describe the earrings as beautiful and brilliant, and many say they look like larger diamond studs. The main complaint is that they arrive smaller than expected.

Pros

Sparkle and shine draw compliments
Size works for both everyday and evening wear
Looks like bigger diamond earrings than the carat weight suggests
Easy online ordering and helpful service

Cons

Some buyers find them smaller than expected

From Macy's

Cluster of round-cut diamonds (1/4 ct. t.w.) in sterling silver
Approximate diameter: 1/2 inch
Diamond color rating code: I-J
Diamond clarity rating code: I3
Diamond cut: Round
Free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating Macy's (no purchase necessary; excludes repairs and professional services)

Materials: Sterling silver with round-cut diamonds
Sizing: Customers on average rate the runs small/runs large as Neutral; some reviewers say the earrings appear smaller than expected, while others find the size just ri
Care: Almost all gemstones have been treated to enhance their beauty and require special care; free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating Macy's (does not includ
Returns: Returns accepted within 30 days of purchase with tags attached; Last Act items are final sale and sold "as is" with no returns, exchanges, or price adjustments
Shipping: This item may not be shipped to U.S. Virgin Islands, Hawaii, Armed Forces Pacific, American Samoa, Marshall Islands, Guam, Puerto Rico, or Palau; fine jewelry m

What buyers say

Buyers like

Described as beautiful, lovely, and brilliant
Noted for shine and sparkle
Size found just right for various occasions
Versatile for everyday and evening wear
Look like larger diamond earrings; draws compliments
Easy, user-friendly online ordering and helpful customer service

Buyers complain about

Some say the earrings appear smaller than expected

Specifications

Material: Sterling Silver
Metal Purity: Sterling Silver
Metal Type: Silver
Metal Color: Silver
Jewelry Type: Earrings, Cluster, Diamond, Stud
Style: Work
Gemstone Carat Weight: 1/4 Carat (t.w.)

Macy's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver

Last price we saw

Ask our shopping agent

Our take on the Macy's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling Silver