- Is $1,225 a good price for these earrings?
- It is the only price seen since October 28, 2026, when it was also $1,225 at Macy's, so there is no cheaper recent point to compare against. For 3/4 ct. t.w. in 14k gold with I2-I3 stones, that is in line with typical mall-jewelry pricing.
- Are these earrings worth it compared with 1 ct. t.w. studs?
- 3/4 ct. t.w. splits into roughly 3/8 ct. per ear, which reads smaller than 1 ct. t.w. but costs noticeably less. If size matters most, save for 1 ct.; if you want a daily pair at a lower price, these are reasonable.
- Will the I2-I3 diamonds look cloudy?
- I2-I3 is the lower end of the clarity scale, so inclusions can be visible at close range and some owners report cloudy stones. HI color helps brightness, but inspect them in person or check the return window before committing.
- Do the screw backs stay on?
- Most owners say they stay in and feel comfortable, but feedback on the screw mechanism is mixed. Screw backs are generally more secure than push backs, though they take longer to put on.
- What comes in the box?
- You get the pair of earrings with screw backs. Macy's typically ships fine jewelry in a gift box, which suits giving them as a present.
- Can I wear them every day?
- Yes. The screw backs and 14k gold suit daily wear, but the treated diamonds need special care, so avoid harsh cleaners and take them off for gym or garden work.
- What do buyers say about the Macy's Diamond Stud Earrings in 14k White or Yellow Gold?
- Rated 4.3 out of 5 from 141 ratings. Buyers like: Beautiful sparkle and clarity; Well-made craftsmanship; Size is perfect for everyday wear or a second piercing. Common complaints: Screw-on backs get mixed feedback on security and function; Earrings appear smaller than anticipated.
