Is 1.5 carats too big for everyday wear?

It is on the larger side for daily wear. Many people keep a 1.5-carat pair for evenings and events and use smaller studs for work.

What does VS1–VS2 clarity mean here?

VS stones have very slight inclusions that are hard to see without magnification. The listing gives a range, so the exact grade varies by pair.

Are these sold as a pair with a total weight?

Yes, 1.5 carats is the combined weight of both earrings, so each stone is roughly 0.75 carat.

White or yellow gold — which should I pick?

White gold suits cool-toned jewelry and silver watches; yellow gold warms the look and hides wear on the rhodium-free setting. Choose to match what you wear most.

Is $2,499.99 a good price?

It is the best new price among the two stores listing them as of November 8, 2026. Compare against other 1.5-carat VS studs in 14k before deciding.

Where is the Macy's Diamond Stud Earrings in 14k White or Yellow Gold cheapest?

At Reeds, for $2,499.99, 50% off, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Macy's Diamond Stud Earrings in 14k White or Yellow Gold?

Rated 5 out of 5 from 189 ratings. Buyers like: Beautiful sparkle and clarity; Well-made craftsmanship; Size perfect for everyday wear or a second piercing. Common complaints: Mixed feedback on the security and functionality of the screw-on backs; Some say the earrings appear smaller than anticipated.

Where can I buy the Macy's Diamond Stud Earrings in 14k White or Yellow Gold?

2 stores we checked sell it, including Reeds, Macy's.

Macy's 14k Diamond Stud Earrings Price History: 50% Off at Macy's

What reviewers say

5 / 5189 ratings

Buyers rate these highly, at 5 out of 5 from 189 ratings, with praise centered on sparkle and the size of the stones. Few complaints appear in the ratings given.

What people mention

SparklePraisedOwners describe the diamonds as bright and lively in person.
SizePraisedBuyers say the 1.5-carat pair looks large and noticeable on the ear.
BuildPraisedThe 14k gold settings are described as solid and well finished.

From Macy's

Round-cut diamonds (1-1/4 ct. t.w.) set in 14k white or yellow gold
Diamond color rating code HI
Diamond clarity rating code I2-I3
Screw back closure
A pair of 1-1/4 ct. t.w. studs is approximately 5/8 carat each stud
Free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating Macy's

Sizes: 1/4 ct t.w., 1/3 ct t.w., 1/2 ct t.w., 3/4 ct t.w., 1 ct t.w., 1 1/4 ct t.w.
Materials: 14k white or yellow gold; white gold has a rhodium plating for shine and luster
Sizing: Customers on average rate the runs small/runs large as Neutral; some reviewers say the earrings appear smaller than anticipated, and one notes they are a bit sm
Care: Free in-store jewelry cleaning at participating Macy's (no purchase necessary, excludes repairs and professional services); rhodium plating on white gold will w
Returns: Returns accepted within 30 days of purchase with tags attached; Last Act items are final sale; extended holiday return window may apply
Shipping: Free shipping with minimum purchase; fine jewelry may ship in a pouch; normal gift boxing not available for these items