Is $43.19 a good price for the Madden Girl Rusty boot?

Yes. These boots usually sell for $60 to $90, so $43.19 at Kohl's as of November 7, 2026 is near the low end. Only two stores list it new, so comparison shopping is limited.

Do the Rusty boots run true to size?

They run close to true to size, but the pointed toe is narrow. Shoppers with wide feet often size up a half size.

Are they comfortable for all-day wear?

Not really. The stacked heel and stiff upper suit short outings better than long days of standing or walking.

What is the heel height?

It is a stacked block heel, roughly 2 to 3 inches, tall enough to change your posture but stable to walk in.

How do I put them on?

They are pull-on boots with no zipper or laces. A boot jack or a little powder helps on the first few wears while the shaft is stiff.

What colors and sizes are available?

The Rusty comes in brown in US women's sizes 6 through 10, including half sizes, though not every size stays in stock.

Where is the Madden Girl Women's Rusty Boots cheapest?

At Kohl's, for $43.19, 52% off, as of our latest check.

Where can I buy the Madden Girl Women's Rusty Boots?

2 stores we checked sell it, including Kohl's, Belk.

Madden Girl Women's Rusty Boots Price History: 52% Off at Kohl's

What reviewers say

Owners of Madden Girl western boots generally like the look for the price and call them comfortable for short wear. Common complaints are stiffness out of the box and a narrow, pinching toe box.

What people mention

StylePraisedBuyers pick these for the pointed toe and stitched western detailing.
ComfortMixedFine for short wear, but owners say long days on feet are uncomfortable.
FitCriticisedThe pointed toe runs narrow and pinches wider feet.
Break-inCriticisedThe upper starts stiff and needs several wears to soften.
ValuePraisedOwners feel the look is good for the price paid.

From Kohl's

Cuff western boot design
Side stitched detail
Pointed toe
Stacked heel
Pull-on closure
Non-skid outsole

Sizes: 5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10, 11
Materials: Microsuede fabric upper; TPR material outsole; jersey fabric lining; polyurethane footbed
Fit: Mid-calf shaft; 7 in. shaft height; 12.5 in. shaft circumference; 0.1 in. platform height; 3.5 in. heel height; flat insole with no built-in arch support
Sizing: Size chart is a general guide and may include sizes unavailable for this item.
Care: Spot clean
Returns: Free in-store returns for 90 days, or 120 days for Kohl's Card holders

Size chart

US Size	Euro Size	Inches	Centimeters
4	35	8.1875	20.8
4.5	35	8.375	21.3
5	35-36	8.5	21.6
5.5	36	8.75	22.2
6	36-37	8.875	22.5
6.5	37	9.0625	23
7	37-38	9.25	23.5
7.5	38	9.375	23.8
8	38-39	9.5	24.1
8.5	39	9.6875	24.6
9	39-40	9.875	25.1
9.5	40	10	25.4